Best Organic Cheese of 2025

Kiera Browne Avatar
Kiera Browne
Last Updated: 8 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Organic cheese is a type of cheese made from milk that is produced without the use of synthetic fertilisers, pesticides, or genetically modified organisms. The cows producing the milk for organic cheese are fed with natural and organic feed, and are not given antibiotics or growth hormones. Organic cheese is known for its rich flavour and quality, and is often preferred by people who are health-conscious and environmentally aware. It is a great addition to any meal or cheese board and is a recommended choice for those who are looking for a healthier and more sustainable option.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Godminster Organic Cheddar Heart 400g Cover #TOP 1
Godminster Organic Cheddar Heart 400g
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Yeo Valley Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese Cover #TOP 2
Yeo Valley Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Booths Organic Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese Cover #TOP 3
Booths Organic Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 9 Organic Cheese

#TOP 1

Godminster Organic Cheddar Heart 400g

Godminster Organic Cheddar Heart 400g Cover
Godminster Organic Cheddar Heart 400g from GREAT BRITISH TRADING LIMITED

Features
The Cheddar Itself Is Matured For Up To 12 Months, At Which Point We Select The Very Best Cheese To Be Made Into One Of Our Award-Winning Truckles.
A Deliciously Soft And Creamy Vintage Organic Cheddar In Our Iconic Heart Shape, Enrobed In Our Distinctive Burgundy Wax
Our Smooth And Rich Vintage Organic Cheddar Is Also Available In A Smaller 200g Size
It Has A Rich Depth Of Flavour Without The Acidity That Is Sometimes Associated With Vintage Cheddar, Giving It A Full And Rounded Flavour With A Smooth And Creamy Texture.
Certified As Organic By The Soil Association And As Such Contain No Artificial Preservatives.
#TOP 2

Yeo Valley Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese

PONLEE
89326
Yeo Valley Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese Cover
Yeo Valley Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese, 300g

Features
Made With Free Range Organic Milk Sourced From British Family Farms.
Organic British Mature Cheddar Cheese From Free Range Cows, Grazing On Lush Pasture.
Suitable For Vegetarians And Anyone Who Loves Organic Food. We Always Strive To Put Nature First.
Naturally High In Calcium, Protein, Iodine, Vitamins B2 And B12, A Natural Source Of Nutrients.
By Buying Yeo Valley Free Range Organic Cheddar Cheese You Are Helping Support Honey Bees. To Find Out More Please Visit Yeovalley.co.uk
#TOP 3

Booths Organic Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese

Booths
473463
Booths Organic Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese Cover
Booths Organic Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese, 250g

Features
Made For Us By Belton Farm In Shropshire
Booths Organic Extra Mature Cheddar Is Intensely Flavoured, Rich And Smooth
Soil Association Organic
Flavour Strength - Extra Strong 4
#TOP 4

Booths Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese

Booths
473464
One Size
Booths Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese Cover
Booths Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese, 250g

Features
Made For Us By Belton Farm In Shropshire
Booths Organic Mature Cheddar Cheese Is Rich, Full Bodied, Firm And Creamy
Soil Association Organic
Flavour Strength - Strong 3
#TOP 5

Odysea Organic Greek Feta Cheese

FT155
Odysea Organic Greek Feta Cheese Cover
Odysea Organic Greek Feta Cheese, 200g

Features
Naturally Low In Lactose
A Rich, Tangy Tasting Feta Cheese Made In Greece With Organic Sheep And Goat's Milk
Suitable For Vegetarians
Crumble Onto Your Salad, Use In Your Cooking, Layer On Your Crackers Or Pop Them In Your Mouth On The Go
Combine With Our Delicious Selection Of Vinegars, Olive Oils, Molasses And Glazes For The Best Results
#TOP 6

Mini Babybel Organic Natural Cheeses 5 x 20g

Mini Babybel
3073781095029
Mini Babybel Organic Natural Cheeses 5 x 20g Cover
Mini Babybel Organic Natural Cheeses 5 x 20g (100g)

Features
100% Organic Cheese - Made With A Full Glass Of Organic Milk In Every Cheese
Naturally Rich In Protein And Calcium
Convenient For Lunchboxes And Snacks
Fine To Eat Whilst You're Pregnant – It's Made From 100% Organic Pasteurised Milk
Free From Added Colours, Flavours Or Preservatives
#TOP 7

Parmareggio Parmigiano Organic Wedges, 150 g

Parmareggio Parmigiano Organic Wedges, 150 g Cover
Parmareggio Parmigiano Organic Wedges, 150 g

Features
Hard Rich Cheese With A Sharp Distinctive Flavour
Organic
Lovely To Cut Into Chunks And Have On Its Own Or Served With Full-Body Red Wine
Genuinely Made In Italy
Can Also Be Grated Over Pasta Or Baked Dishes To Enhance Flavours
150g
#TOP 8

San Salvatore Organic Buffalo Mozzarella

San Salvatore
8032589051083
San Salvatore Organic Buffalo Mozzarella Cover
San Salvatore Organic Buffalo Mozzarella, 125g

Features
It Is Also Common In Popular Italian Dishes Like Lasagne And Baked Casserole
The Cheese Goes Well In Antipasti Dishes, With Salads, Pastas, Calzones, Vegetables And Various Side Dishes
When Used In Cooking, Heated Mozzarella Becomes Slightly Creamy
Ready To Serve
Country Of Origin: Italy

Premium Quality Raclette Cheese for Melting

Premium Quality Raclette Cheese for Melting Cover
Raclette Cheese | Premium Quality | 1 kilo / 2.2 lbs Block Soft Cheese for Melting and for Fondue - Premium Quality French Cheese Wheel Piece from GREAT BRITISH TRADING LIMITED

The Raclette Cheese Block is ideal for melting, making it a perfect choice for your raclette night. Its soft texture allows you to slice and warm it until it becomes smooth and creamy, enhancing the rich taste of the mountains. This French cheese from Entremont is not only great for traditional raclette but also adds a delicious touch to fondue. You can pair it with meats, potatoes, and vegetables for a delightful meal that will impress your guests.

What We Like
Perfect for melting
Rich mountain flavour
Great for fondue
Versatile with various foods
Buying Guide Image
Editor's Notes

During our organic cheese research, we found 104 organic cheese products and shortlisted 9 quality products. We collected and analyzed 5,201 customer reviews through our big data system to write the organic cheese list. We found that most customers choose organic cheese with an average price of £20.00.

The organic cheese are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of organic cheese, including GREAT BRITISH TRADING LIMITED, PONLEE, Booths, Odysea, Mini Babybel. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 570 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.

Written by
Kiera Browne Avatar

Kiera Browne served as chef and caterer in Purslane Restaurant for three years before establishing her restaurant. Kiera now owns two restaurants and a culinary school all over the United Kingdom. Kiera has featured in magazines and editorials, providing recipes for various dishes. Using her skills and knowledge in the culinary field, Kiera has published few pamphlets on preparing various cuisines.