Best Organic Sugar Substitutes of 2025

Kiera Browne Avatar
Kiera Browne
Last Updated: 2 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Organic sugar substitutes are a range of sweeteners made from natural sources that can be used as a healthier alternative to refined sugar. These products are made from organic ingredients and are free from artificial sweeteners, colours, and flavours. They are perfect for those who want to reduce their sugar intake without compromising on taste. Organic sugar substitutes come in different forms, such as granules, liquid, or powder, and can be used in a variety of recipes, including baking, cooking, and drinks. They are also suitable for vegans and those with dietary restrictions.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Castello Erythritol Organic Sugar Substitute Cover #TOP 1
Castello Erythritol Organic Sugar Substitute
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Xylitol Natural Sugar Substitute - 3kg Cover #TOP 2
Xylitol Natural Sugar Substitute - 3kg
ftb score rating icon 9.8
BIONA Organic Wholecane Sugar 500g Cover #TOP 3
BIONA Organic Wholecane Sugar 500g
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Organic Sugar Substitutes

#TOP 1

Castello Erythritol Organic Sugar Substitute

720 g (Pack of 1)
Castello Erythritol Organic Sugar Substitute Cover
Castello since 1907 Erythritol Sweetener Organic Bio Eco | 144 sachets of 5g | Sugar Substitute - Keto and Paleo Friendly - 0 Glycemic - 0 Calories - 0 Net Carbs - Made by corn 100% Non-GMO - 720 g

Castello Erythritol is an ideal choice for those seeking a healthy sugar substitute. It is made from 100% certified Non-GMO corn, ensuring that you are consuming a safe product free from genetically modified organisms. This sweetener is perfect for various diets, including Keto and Paleo, as it has a glycemic index of 0, making it suitable for diabetics. With 0 calories and 0 carbohydrates, you can enjoy sweetness without worrying about calorie intake. Additionally, it dissolves easily in both hot and cold beverages, allowing for versatile use in your cooking and baking.

What We Like
Organic and eco-friendly
Non-GMO certified
0 calories, 0 carbs
Safe for diabetics
Dissolves easily in liquids
#TOP 2

Xylitol Natural Sugar Substitute - 3kg

489443
Xylitol Natural Sugar Substitute - 3kg Cover
Xylitol Sweetener - 3kg Natural Sugar Substitute, Keto Sweetener, Diabetic Sugar, Organic Xylitol Sugar Alternative

Xylitol Sugar Alternative is a natural sweetener that allows you to embrace healthier choices in your diet. It serves as an excellent sugar substitute for those on keto or managing diabetes, helping you maintain stable blood sugar levels. This versatile sweetening solution is perfect for cooking, baking, and beverages without leaving any unpleasant aftertaste. Additionally, using this xylitol can improve your dental health by reducing tooth decay, making it a smart choice for satisfying your sweet cravings while taking care of your teeth.

What We Like
Natural and pure sweetener
Keto and diabetic friendly
Versatile for various recipes
Supports dental health
Eco-conscious and organic
#TOP 3

BIONA Organic Wholecane Sugar 500g

6598
500 g (Pack of 1)
BIONA Organic Wholecane Sugar 500g Cover
BIONA Organic Rapadura/Sucanat Wholecane Sugar 500g

BIONA Wholecane Sugar is a delightful sweetener that captures the rich essence of unrefined sugar cane juice. You can use it in all your favourite foods and drinks, adding a delicious caramel flavour that enhances the taste. Its fine-grained texture makes it ideal for baking and desserts, ensuring even sweetness in every bite. Plus, as it contains certified organic ingredients, you can feel good about what you are adding to your meals.

What We Like
Unrefined sugar for natural sweetness
Rich caramel flavour
Great for baking
Fine grained texture
Certified organic ingredients
#TOP 4

Organic Unrefined Cane Sugar (Panela/Rapadura) 1kg

1 kg (Pack of 1)
Organic Unrefined Cane Sugar (Panela/Rapadura) 1kg Cover
Organic Unrefined Cane Sugar (Panela/Rapadura) 1kg (BWFO)

Organic Cane Sugar 1kg is an excellent substitute for Muscovado or Demerara sugar in your recipes. Being unrefined, it offers a healthier alternative to other sugars, allowing you to enjoy sweet treats without compromising on health. Its unique flavour features a delightful caramel sensation, complemented by hints of toffee and liquorice, enhancing your dishes. Additionally, this product is now 100% recyclable, making it an environmentally friendly choice for your kitchen.

What We Like
Healthier sugar alternative
Rich caramel flavour
Great for baking
100% recyclable packaging
#TOP 5

Forest Whole Foods Organic Date Sugar 1kg

1 kg (Pack of 1)
Forest Whole Foods Organic Date Sugar 1kg Cover
Organic Date Sugar - Forest Whole Foods (1kg)

Forest Whole Foods Date Sugar is a nutrient-rich sweetener that offers a delightful butterscotch flavour. Made by drying and grinding dates, this sugar retains all the beneficial nutrients found in dried dates. It’s perfect for enhancing your baking recipes, adding a natural sweetness to raw desserts, or simply sweetening your hot drinks. With its dense, golden brown appearance, this organic date sugar not only elevates your culinary creations but also ensures you enjoy a healthier alternative to refined sugars.

What We Like
Organic and nutrient-rich
Delicious butterscotch flavour
Versatile for various recipes
Great for sweetening drinks
#TOP 6

Thames Organic Cane Sugar - 1 kg Natural Sweetener

682895653945
1 kg (Pack of 1)
Thames Organic Cane Sugar - 1 kg Natural Sweetener Cover
Organic Cane Sugar - No Additives or Preservatives, Vegan, GMO Free, Certified Organic - Perfect for Baking and Sweetening Drinks Naturally - Thames Organic 1 kg

Thames Organic Cane Sugar is a fantastic choice for those seeking a natural sweetener. Made from 100% organic cane sugar, it is sustainably grown and harvested, ensuring quality and environmental care. With no additives or preservatives, you can enjoy a vegan-friendly option that is perfect for both baking and sweetening drinks. This unrefined sugar retains a rich molasses flavour and essential nutrients, making your recipes not only sweeter but also more nutritious. It’s an ideal alternative to artificial sweeteners, allowing you to indulge naturally.

What We Like
100% organic and sustainable
No additives or preservatives
Rich molasses flavour
Vegan-friendly option
Lower glycemic index
#TOP 7

Trend Organic Cane Sugar for Culinary Uses

Trend Organic
TR_Cane_Sugar_500g
500 g (Pack of 1)
Trend Organic Cane Sugar for Culinary Uses Cover
Trend Organic Cane Sugar Ideal for Sweetening Your Culinary Creations - Certified Organic Sweetness, Pure, Unrefined, and Sustainably Sourced - Vegan, Non-GMO, No Additives, No Preservatives, 500g

Trend Organic Cane Sugar is a nutrient-rich natural sweetener that offers a delightful addition to your cooking. Packed with essential vitamins and minerals, this unrefined sugar not only sweetens your dishes but also contributes to your overall health. Its unrefined goodness retains natural molasses, providing a richer flavour and healthier alternative to white sugar. With its culinary versatility, you can enhance beverages, desserts, marinades, and sauces, making it an ideal choice for your culinary creations while ensuring a mindful approach to sweetening.

What We Like
Nutrient-rich and healthy
Unrefined for better flavour
Versatile for many dishes
Vegan and non-GMO
No additives or preservatives
#TOP 8

BIONA Organic Rapadura Wholecane Sugar 500g Pack

BI-RAP
500 g (Pack of 3)
BIONA Organic Rapadura Wholecane Sugar 500g Pack Cover
BIONA Organic Rapadura/Sucanat Wholecane Sugar 500g (PACK OF 3)

BIONA Wholecane Sugar is a delightful unrefined sweetener that captures the essence of sugar cane juice. Its fine-grained texture and delicious caramel flavour make it perfect for enhancing all types of foods and drinks. Whether you're baking or preparing desserts, this organic sugar adds a rich sweetness that elevates your culinary creations. As it is made from certified organic ingredients, you can enjoy your treats knowing they are made with natural goodness.

What We Like
Unrefined sugar for natural sweetness
Great for baking and desserts
Delicious caramel flavour
Fine grained texture
Organic ingredients certified
#TOP 9

Sweet Natured Organic Agave Nectar Sweetener 350g

Sweet Natured
350 g (Pack of 1)
Sweet Natured Organic Agave Nectar Sweetener 350g Cover
Sweet Natured Organic Agave Nectar Sweetener – 100% Natural, Vegan, and Perfect for Baking, Breakfast & Tea – Powdered Sugar Texture with Honey Taste, 350g

Sweet Natured Agave Nectar is a 100% natural sweetener derived from high-quality agave plants. Its honey-like taste in a powdered form allows you to enjoy a rich sweetness while keeping your meals vegan-friendly. You will find it perfect for baking, drizzling on pancakes, or enhancing your morning tea. Being naturally sweeter than sugar means you can use less, making it a healthier choice for your recipes. Plus, it has no unpleasant aftertaste, ensuring a delightful experience with every use.

What We Like
100% organic and natural
Versatile for various uses
No aftertaste
Sweeter than sugar
Gut-friendly prebiotics
#TOP 10

Heaven & Earth Organic Date Sugar 340g

HEAVEN & EARTH
Heaven & Earth Organic Date Sugar 340g Cover
Heaven & Earth Pure Organic Date Sugar 340g | All Natural Alternative Sweetener, Low Glycemic, Good Source of Fiber, Great Sugar Replacement

Heaven & Earth Date Sugar is a delicious and rich alternative to conventional sugars. Made from 100% organic dates, it is a healthier choice as it is low glycemic and vegan-friendly. This natural sweetener can be sprinkled over cereals, fruit, and yogurt, making breakfast more enjoyable. You can also add it to smoothies or use it in baking, ensuring your dishes are naturally sweetened. With its simple ingredients, it offers a great way to enrich your diet with fibre, vitamins, and antioxidants.

What We Like
Natural sweetness
100% organic ingredients
Low glycemic index
Versatile for various uses
Rich in fibre and nutrients
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is the healthiest sugar substitute 2020?

Stevia — in packet, drops or plant form — is a dietitian favorite. Not only does it contain zero calories, but stevia-based sweeteners are herbal as opposed to artificial.

Editor's Notes

During our organic sugar substitute research, we found 77 organic sugar substitute products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 5,600 customer reviews through our big data system to write the organic sugar substitutes list. We found that most customers choose organic sugar substitutes with an average price of £6.49.

The organic sugar substitutes are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of organic sugar substitutes, including Castello since 1907, Xylitol, Biona, BWFO, Forest Whole Foods. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 129 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.

Written by
Kiera Browne Avatar

Kiera Browne served as chef and caterer in Purslane Restaurant for three years before establishing her restaurant. Kiera now owns two restaurants and a culinary school all over the United Kingdom. Kiera has featured in magazines and editorials, providing recipes for various dishes. Using her skills and knowledge in the culinary field, Kiera has published few pamphlets on preparing various cuisines.