Best Natural Vanilla Extracts of 2025

Kiera Browne Avatar
Kiera Browne
Last Updated: 9 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Natural Vanilla Extracts are a popular ingredient used in a variety of sweet dishes and baked goods. Made from real vanilla beans, these extracts are known for their rich and complex flavour profile that adds depth and warmth to any recipe. They are a versatile ingredient that can be used in everything from cakes and cookies to ice cream and custards. While there are many different types of vanilla extracts available on the market, natural extracts are preferred by many due to their high quality and authentic flavour.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Dr Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract 35ml Pack Cover #TOP 1
Dr Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract 35ml Pack
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Baron Vanilla Essence 155ml for Baking Cover #TOP 2
Baron Vanilla Essence 155ml for Baking
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Dr. Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract, 95ml Cover #TOP 3
Dr. Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract, 95ml
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Natural Vanilla Extracts

#TOP 1

Dr Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract 35ml Pack

dutis
35 ml (Pack of 3)
Dr Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract 35ml Pack Cover
Dr Oetker Natural Extract Madagascan Vanilla | 35ml (3 pack)

Dr Oetker Vanilla Extract is a delightful addition to your baking essentials. This pack includes three 35ml bottles of high-quality Madagascan vanilla extract, perfect for enhancing the flavour of your cakes, cookies, and desserts. Using this natural extract can elevate your recipes, providing a rich and aromatic taste that is sure to impress. With its convenient packaging, you can easily reach for a bottle whenever you need to add a touch of luxury to your cooking. It's an essential ingredient for any home baker looking to achieve professional results.

What We Like
High-quality natural extract
Convenient pack of three
Enhances flavour in baking
Easy to use
#TOP 2

Baron Vanilla Essence 155ml for Baking

Baron Vanilla Essence 155ml for Baking Cover
Baron Vanilla Essence 155ml | Pure and Natural Vanilla Flavor | Rich & Aromatic | Extract for Baking, Desserts, and Beverages | Vanilla Flavoring for Cakes & Cookies

Baron Vanilla Essence is crafted from premium quality vanilla beans, ensuring a rich and authentic flavour that enhances your culinary creations. With its deep, aromatic taste, each drop elevates the flavour of your baked goods, desserts, and even savoury dishes. This versatile essence is perfect for a variety of applications, from cakes and cookies to ice creams and sauces. You will appreciate its natural composition, free from artificial additives, which means you are adding pure flavour to your recipes.

What We Like
Rich, authentic flavour
Versatile for many recipes
No artificial additives
Easy to measure and use

Dr. Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract, 95ml

1-30-011646
95 ml (Pack of 1)
Dr. Oetker Madagascan Vanilla Extract, 95ml Cover
Dr. Oetker Large Madagascan Vanilla Extract, 95ml

The Dr. Oetker Vanilla Extract is made from real Madagascan vanilla pods, ensuring a rich and authentic flavour for your baking. This extract is suitable for vegans, making it a versatile choice for everyone. The larger 95ml bottle is perfect for frequent bakers, providing plenty of extract for all your recipes. Using this vanilla extract can elevate your cakes, cookies, and desserts, giving them a delightful aroma and taste that will impress family and friends.

What We Like
Made from real vanilla pods
Vegan-friendly option
Large 95ml bottle
Enhances baking flavour
#TOP 4

Pure & Natural Real Vanilla Extract with Seeds

100 ml (Pack of 1)
Pure & Natural Real Vanilla Extract with Seeds Cover
Pure & Natural Real Vanilla Extract, with Seeds. Made with Premium Bourbon Vanilla

L'Artisan Vanilla Extract offers a rich, pure flavour with high vanillin content, ensuring a delightful taste in your baking and cooking. The inclusion of vanilla seeds adds an attractive flecking to your dishes, enhancing their presentation. Unlike synthetic alternatives, this extract is free from additives and preservatives, allowing you to enjoy the true essence of vanilla. For the best results, heat the extract with your liquids, ensuring that you experience the full depth of flavour in hot drinks like coffee or milk.

What We Like
High vanillin content
Includes vanilla seeds
Pure and natural formula
Enhances flavour in hot drinks

Bonilla Madagascan Pure Vanilla Extract, 50ml

BONILLA MADAGASCAN
Brown
50ml (Pack of 1)
Bonilla Madagascan Pure Vanilla Extract, 50ml Cover
Bonilla Madagascan - Pure Vanilla Extract, 50ml - 100% Pure Madagascan Vanilla Beans - Premium Vanilla Flavour - For Baking, Custards & Cream - Non-GMO, Kosher, Gluten-free, Vegan

Bonilla Vanilla Extract is a premium choice for your baking needs. This pure vanilla extract uses 50g of the finest Bourbon vanilla beans in every litre, providing a rich, mellow flavour perfect for custards, creams, and cheesecakes. Made only from natural ingredients, it is free from synthetic additives, gluten, and GMOs, ensuring a clean taste. Its versatility shines in high-fat, low-liquid recipes, making it ideal for desserts like Crème Brûlée and Vanilla Panna Cotta. Experience the smooth vanilla flavour that this extract brings to your culinary creations.

What We Like
Rich, mellow vanilla flavour
Natural, synthetic-free ingredients
Versatile for various recipes
Kosher-certified and vegan-friendly
#TOP 6

Kiddu 100ml Pure Vanilla Extract for Baking

Kiddu
100 ml (Pack of 1)
Kiddu 100ml Pure Vanilla Extract for Baking Cover
Kiddu - 100ml Pure Vanilla Extract for Home Baking, Made from Premium Vanilla Pods

Kiddu Vanilla Extract is a 100% pure and rich dark vanilla extract, perfect for enhancing your baking creations. Aged for many months, it contains no added ingredients apart from alcohol and water, ensuring a genuine vanilla taste. Its intense flavour, derived from premium Ugandan vanilla pods, is versatile enough to meet all your baking needs. By choosing this product, you support direct trade practices, as Kiddu maintains personal relationships with smallholder farmers in Uganda, ensuring quality and sustainability.

What We Like
100% pure vanilla extract
Rich, intense flavour
Supports smallholder farmers
Versatile for various baking needs
Artisanal batches for quality
#TOP 7

Taylor & Colledge Vanilla Bean Extract 100ml Pack of 2

Taylor & Colledge Vanilla Bean Extract 100ml Pack of 2 Cover
Taylor & Colledge Vanilla Bean Extract 100ml - Pack of 2 with World Food Shop Scoop | Pure Vanilla Extract | Natural Bourbon Vanilla Beans

Taylor & Colledge Vanilla Extract offers a premium quality, pure vanilla flavour sourced from natural Bourbon vanilla beans. Each pack contains two 100ml bottles, ensuring you have a steady supply for all your baking and cooking needs. The included World Food Shop Scoop allows you to measure the perfect amount for your recipes, making it easier to achieve consistent results. This extract is perfect for enhancing the taste of various dishes, bringing a rich and authentic gourmet vanilla flavour to your culinary creations.

What We Like
High-quality vanilla extract
Convenient measuring scoop included
Perfect for baking and cooking
Pack of 2 for steady supply

Baking Extracts Bundle with Dr Oetker Flavours

Credo Gifts
Baking Extracts Bundle with Dr Oetker Flavours Cover
Baking Extracts Bundle With Dr Oetker Sicilian Lemon Natural Extract 35ml, Madagascan Vanilla Extract 35ml and Natural Zesty Orange Extract 35ml (3 Pack)

The Dr Oetker Baking Extracts offer pure flavour enhancement, allowing you to elevate the taste of your baked goods and savoury dishes without relying on artificial additives. Made from high-quality ingredients like Sicilian lemons and Madagascan vanilla beans, these extracts provide versatile options for various recipes. Their convenient liquid form makes it easy for you to measure and control the intensity of flavours, ensuring consistent results each time you bake. Moreover, their aromatic profiles inspire culinary creativity, encouraging you to experiment with new flavour combinations.

What We Like
Natural and intense flavours
Suitable for various recipes
Easy to measure and use
Encourages culinary creativity
#TOP 9

Vanillabazaar Organic Madagascan Vanilla Extract 50ml

Vanillabazaar
EXT200C_50ORG
50ml No Seeds
Vanillabazaar Organic Madagascan Vanilla Extract 50ml Cover
Vanillabazaar 100% Natural, Alcohol Free, Purity Organic Madagascan Vanilla Extract for Home Baking and Flavouring for Beverages including Hot Drinks and Smoothies (50ml)

Vanillabazaar Vanilla Extract is a 100% alcohol-free and natural product, perfect for enhancing your baking and beverages. The sustainable extraction process ensures a concentrated vanilla taste, allowing you to enjoy the rich flavour without any artificial additives. Ethical sourcing means you can feel good about your purchase, supporting Madagascan communities. This organic extract is versatile for both hot and cold drinks, as well as desserts, giving you the authentic taste of real vanilla with added convenience.

What We Like
Alcohol-free and natural
Concentrated vanilla flavour
Ethically sourced ingredients
Versatile for various recipes
Organic and vegan-friendly

Zazou Emporium Pure Madagascar Vanilla Extract

Zazou Emporium Vanilla
118ml
Zazou Emporium Pure Madagascar Vanilla Extract Cover
Zazou Emporium - 118ml Pure Vanilla Extract - Made with 100% Madagascar Vanilla Beans - Perfect for Baking and Home Cooking

Zazou Emporium Vanilla Extract is crafted from 100% Madagascar vanilla beans, ensuring a pure and authentic flavour without any additives, sugar, or colourants. The state-of-the-art extraction process captures all 300 flavour compounds, enhancing your baking and cooking. With sustainably sourced ingredients, you can feel good knowing that your purchase supports over 7000 farmers in Madagascar. As a family-run business, Zazou Emporium is committed to providing unmatched quality and education about the wonderful world of vanilla.

What We Like
100% pure Madagascar vanilla
Rich, delicious flavour
Sustainably sourced ingredients
Supports local farmers
Family-run business
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is natural vanilla flavor real vanilla?

Therefore, vanillin made from bacterial fermentation of corn or rice bran is a "natural" vanilla flavor – just not "real" vanilla flavor. However, vanillin made from cow dung, while natural in all senses, is not legally "natural", because dung normally isn't a source of food.

2. Is natural vanilla flavor the same as vanilla extract?

Vanilla Extract: What's the Difference? Vanilla flavoring uses artificial ingredients and additives like synthetic vanillin, corn syrup, and lignin, an ingredient typically extracted from wood pulp. By contrast, pure vanilla extract uses only two ingredients: real vanilla beans and alcohol.

3. Is natural vanilla extract healthy?

It's good for your heart – research has shown that vanilla can reduce cholesterol levels. This is very important for those who are at high risk of heart attacks and strokes, with lower cholesterol helping to prevent inflammation of the arteries and blood clots.

4. What is the difference between vanilla and natural vanilla?

The only real difference between the two is their origin. Natural flavors technically have to start as something that resembles food. Artificial flavors, on the other hand, are derived from man-made chemicals. Shop Now!

Editor's Notes

During our natural vanilla extract research, we found 77 natural vanilla extract products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 15,403 customer reviews through our big data system to write the natural vanilla extracts list. We found that most customers choose natural vanilla extracts with an average price of £11.82.

The natural vanilla extracts are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of natural vanilla extracts, including dutis, Gharana Swaad Ka Khazaana, Dr. Oetker, L'Artisan Vanilla Company, BONILLA MADAGASCAN. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 1,323 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.

Written by
Kiera Browne Avatar

Kiera Browne served as chef and caterer in Purslane Restaurant for three years before establishing her restaurant. Kiera now owns two restaurants and a culinary school all over the United Kingdom. Kiera has featured in magazines and editorials, providing recipes for various dishes. Using her skills and knowledge in the culinary field, Kiera has published few pamphlets on preparing various cuisines.