Best Butter Fudge of 2025

Kiera Browne Avatar
Kiera Browne
Last Updated: 2 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Butter fudge is a delicious and indulgent treat that is made with simple ingredients like sugar, butter, and cream. This creamy and rich confectionery comes in a variety of flavours, including vanilla, chocolate, and caramel. Butter fudge is perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth or as a thoughtful gift for a loved one. Its soft and smooth texture melts in your mouth and leaves a delightful aftertaste. Whether you enjoy it as a snack or as a dessert, butter fudge is a must-try for all those who love sweet treats.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality Cover #TOP 1
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality Cover #TOP 2
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Farrah's Olde English Butter Fudge Tin Cover #TOP 3
Farrah's Olde English Butter Fudge Tin
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Butter Fudge

Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality

Bon Bons
BF300
150 g (Pack of 1)
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality Cover
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Artisanal Small Batch Production Hand Packaged Premium Quality Ingredients Delicious Flavour Great Gift Idea Luxury Confectionery Vegetarian - 150 g Pack

Bon Bons All Butter Fudge is crafted in small batches by some of Britain's finest artisans, ensuring top-notch quality. This fudge is hand-packaged with care, so you can enjoy the attention to detail that goes into every piece. Being vegetarian-friendly, it’s a delightful treat for everyone, although it does contain milk and may have traces of nuts. Sourced from across the UK and Europe, the quality ingredients guarantee a delicious flavour that harkens back to the charm of traditional sweet shops.

What We Like
Small batch production
Hand-packaged with care
Vegetarian-friendly
High-quality ingredients
#TOP 2

Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality

Bon Bons
BF300
150 g (Pack of 2)
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Premium Quality Cover
Bon Bons Gourmet All Butter Fudge - Artisanal Small Batch Production Hand Packaged Premium Quality Ingredients Delicious Flavour Great Gift Idea Luxury Confectionery Vegetarian - 150 g Pack

Bon Bons All Butter Fudge is crafted in small batches by skilled artisan producers, ensuring each piece is made with the highest quality ingredients. This hand-packaged treat is not only delectable but also vegetarian-friendly, making it a great choice for a variety of diets. You can indulge in the rich flavours knowing that the fudge is sourced from the best suppliers across the UK and Europe. With Bon Bons, you experience a luxurious taste that harkens back to the charm of traditional sweet shops.

What We Like
Small batch production
Hand packaged with care
Vegetarian friendly
High-quality ingredients
Traditional sweet shop flavour
#TOP 3

Farrah's Olde English Butter Fudge Tin

FARRAH'S
200 g (Pack of 1)
Farrah's Olde English Butter Fudge Tin Cover
Farrah's of Harrogate - Olde English Butter Fudge (200g) - Gifting Olde English Embossed Reusable Tin Filled With Traditionally Handmade Luxury Fudge, Rich Heritage Dating Back To 1840

Farrah's Butter Fudge comes in a beautiful 200g silver and blue embossed tin, making it an elegant gift option. This fudge is the original Harrogate Butter Fudge, offering a rich heritage that dates back to 1840. It is made using three types of sugar, ensuring a gorgeously creamy texture and delightful taste that you will surely enjoy. Being traditionally handmade, it promises a quality that is both authentic and luxurious, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth or treating a loved one.

What We Like
Rich and creamy texture
Traditionally handmade
Elegant reusable tin
Established brand since 1840
#TOP 4

Morrisons The Best All Butter Fudge 150g

109214942
Morrisons The Best All Butter Fudge 150g Cover
Morrisons The Best All Butter Fudge, 150g

Morrisons All Butter Fudge is the perfect treat for those who appreciate quality sweets. Made with Yorkshire cream butter, this fudge offers a rich and creamy texture that will delight your taste buds. Once opened, storing it in an airtight container ensures that the fudge remains fresh and indulgent for longer, allowing you to enjoy it at your leisure. With this exquisite treat, you can satisfy your sweet tooth or share it with friends and family during special occasions.

What We Like
Rich buttery flavour
Uses Yorkshire cream butter
Stays fresh in airtight container
Perfect for sharing or gifting
#TOP 5

Melting Pot Fudge - Traditional Butter Fudge 90g

Melting Pot Fudge
Traditional Butter
90 g (Pack of 1)
Melting Pot Fudge - Traditional Butter Fudge 90g Cover
Melting Pot Fudge - Traditional Butter Fudge 90g

The Melting Pot Traditional Fudge is a delightful treat, crafted with the finest Irish butter for an indulgent taste. Winning a gold star at the Great Taste Awards 2015, this handmade butter fudge promises exceptional quality that you can enjoy. Weighing in at 90 grams, it is the perfect size for a sweet snack or a thoughtful gift. You will appreciate the traditional recipe that evokes a sense of nostalgia, making each bite a comforting experience.

What We Like
Gold star award-winning flavour
Handmade quality
Uses finest Irish butter
Perfect gift size
#TOP 6

Cartwright & Butler Salted Caramel Fudge Carton

175 g (Pack of 1)
Cartwright & Butler Salted Caramel Fudge Carton Cover
Cartwright & Butler Salted Caramel Fudge Carton | Rich, Creamy and Crumbly Fudge Made with Sea Salt | Traditional All Butter Fudge - Salted Caramel Fudge,pack of1

The Salted Caramel Fudge offers a delightful treat for those seeking something special. Made with sea salt, this buttery and crumbly fudge is perfect for sharing with friends and family. Its traditional all-butter recipe from Scotland ensures a rich and creamy experience that is ideal for an after-dinner indulgence. You can elevate your dinner parties by serving this fudge alongside a lovely cup of Earl Grey or Afternoon Dinner Blend Coffee, making it a must-have for tea time.

What We Like
Rich, creamy texture
Perfect for sharing
Ideal after dinner treat
Great with tea or coffee
Lovely gift option
#TOP 7

Cartwright and Butler Classic Butter Fudge Tin

175 g (Pack of 1)
Cartwright and Butler Classic Butter Fudge Tin Cover
Cartwright and Butler Classic Butter Fudge in Tin 175g

The Classic Butter Fudge offers an exceptionally creamy texture that melts in your mouth, making it a delightful treat for any occasion. Crafted from luxury ingredients, its rich colour is a testament to its quality. You will appreciate that this fudge is free from additives or preservatives, ensuring a pure and indulgent experience. Perfect for sharing, it’s a wonderful way to enjoy sweet moments with your loved ones.

What We Like
Exceptionally creamy texture
Luxury ingredients used
Free from additives
Perfect for sharing
#TOP 8

Copperpot Caramel and Sea Salt Fudge

Copperpot
CIN001118
Caramel
150 g (Pack of 1)
Copperpot Caramel and Sea Salt Fudge Cover
Copperpot Caramel & Sea Salt Butter Fudge - 150g

The Copperpot Fudge offers a delightful combination of caramel and sea salt, bringing you the best of both worlds. This unique blend enhances the rich, buttery flavour, making it a perfect treat for sweet lovers. Each piece is expertly crafted to crumble on your tongue, delivering a melting sensation that you won’t forget. With its creamy texture, this fudge is filled with butter, milk, and golden syrup, ensuring each bite is indulgently satisfying and a true taste of England's finest fudge makers.

What We Like
Delicious caramel and sea salt
Melts in your mouth
Crafted with quality ingredients
Unique flavour combination
#TOP 9

Copperpot Maple Syrup Butter Fudge - 150g

Copperpot
CIN001186
150 g (Pack of 1)
Copperpot Maple Syrup Butter Fudge - 150g Cover
Copperpot Maple Syrup Butter Fudge - 150g

Copperpot Maple Syrup Fudge is crafted with the finest Canadian maple syrup sourced from Quebec's “Sugarwoods.” This delicious fudge offers delicate notes of butterscotch and crème caramel, providing a rich flavour experience. You’ll love how each piece crumbles on your tongue, delivering a melting, buttery bliss that is simply irresistible. Plus, it is gluten-free, alcohol-free, and suitable for vegetarians, making it a delightful treat for a wide range of dietary preferences.

What We Like
High-quality Canadian ingredients
Delicious butterscotch flavour
Gluten-free and vegetarian-friendly
Melts in the mouth

Bonnie Glen Handmade Scottish Vanilla Fudge

Bonnie Glen
Bonnie Glen Handmade Scottish Vanilla Fudge Cover
Scottish Fudge: Bonnie Glen - Handmade Traditional Scottish Vanilla Fudge - 150g Pouch, Artisanal Premium Quality Ingredients, Delicious Flavour, Great Gift Idea, Luxury Confectionery, Vegetarian

Bonnie Glen Vanilla Fudge is a luxurious treat crafted with premium ingredients and a traditional recipe. Its artisanal flavour is achieved through hand pouring and scoring, ensuring a smooth vanilla taste that melts in your mouth. Winning a Great Taste Award, this fudge boasts an enticing butterscotch aroma, making it a delightful choice for any occasion. You’ll love sharing this mouthwatering confection with friends and family, as each buttery bite is a true indulgence that brings joy to every gathering.

What We Like
Luxurious and indulgent treat
Handmade for superior quality
Award-winning taste
Perfect gift idea
Great for sharing
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What does adding butter to fudge do?

Use corn syrup and butter Both interfere with sugar crystallization, so adding them to the fudge prevents the crystals from growing too large. Butter should be added only after the boiling is done. If added before boiling, it coats the crystals and keeps them from dissolving, resulting in grainy fudge.

2. What kind of butter do you use for fudge?

Use unsalted butter so you can add a small amount of salt (¼ teaspoon per stick of butter) to the sugar/liquid mixture. Salt tends to stabilize the mixture and keep it from foaming as much. The secret to perfect fudge is…

3. Can you make fudge with butter instead of margarine?

When making fudge, be sure to use good quality butter and do not substitute margarine. Margarine contains more water and can prevent the fudge from setting up properly. Also, be sure to use the quantity called for in the recipe, too much may prevent it from firming up properly.

Editor's Notes

During our butter fudge research, we found 101 butter fudge products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 17,316 customer reviews through our big data system to write the butter fudge list. We found that most customers choose butter fudge with an average price of £5.56.

The butter fudge are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of butter fudge, including Bon Bons, FARRAH'S, Morrisons, Melting Pot Fudge, Cartwright & Butler.

Written by
Kiera Browne Avatar

Kiera Browne served as chef and caterer in Purslane Restaurant for three years before establishing her restaurant. Kiera now owns two restaurants and a culinary school all over the United Kingdom. Kiera has featured in magazines and editorials, providing recipes for various dishes. Using her skills and knowledge in the culinary field, Kiera has published few pamphlets on preparing various cuisines.