Best Refill Eyeshadows of 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Refill eyeshadows are a convenient and eco-friendly way to enjoy your favourite eye colours without having to purchase a new compact each time. These compact and easy-to-use refills allow you to easily replace your used eyeshadow pans, reducing waste and saving you money. With a wide range of colours and finishes available, you can easily customise your makeup collection to suit your personal style and preferences. Whether you prefer matte, shimmer, or glitter finishes, refill eyeshadows offer a versatile and cost-effective way to keep your makeup collection up-to-date.
At a Glance: Our Top Picks
Top 10 Refill Eyeshadows
MAC Pro Palette Eye Shadow Refill - Rice Paper
The MAC Eye Shadow Refill offers a beautiful peachy gold shade with a shimmer finish, perfect for adding a touch of glamour to your look. This refill is designed for the MAC Pro Palette, allowing you to customise your eye makeup collection easily. The frosted texture provides a smooth application and blends effortlessly, making it suitable for both everyday wear and special occasions. Enjoy the convenience of a high-quality eye shadow that enhances your eyes and complements various skin tones.
Trish McEvoy Classic Lucky Eye Shadow Refill
The Trish McEvoy Lucky Eye Shadow offers a silky, luminous finish that enhances your lids with vibrant colour. It glides on effortlessly, ensuring a long-lasting look that won't fade. You can easily blend and build the colour to achieve your desired style. Whether you want a subtle wash of colour or a more defined look with darker shades in the crease, this eye shadow provides the versatility you need for any occasion.
Benecos Organic Vegan Eyeshadow Refill Cream
The Benecos Eyeshadow Refill offers highly pigmented colour that enhances your makeup palette. Formulated to be easy to blend, this eyeshadow allows you to create a flawless look with minimal effort. It contains a care complex featuring organic corn starch, avocado oil, and jojoba oil, which nourishes your skin while you wear it. Plus, being talc-free means you can enjoy a more natural application without harmful additives, making it perfect for sensitive skin.
Trish McEvoy Café Latte Eye Shadow Refill
The Trish McEvoy Eye Shadow offers a silky, pigment-rich formula that provides a stunning luminous shimmer finish. It glides effortlessly onto your eyelids, ensuring a stay-true colour that lasts throughout the day. You can easily blend and build this eye shadow, allowing you to create any desired look with convenience. Whether you wish to apply a sheer wash of colour or enhance your eyes with dimension, this versatile product is designed to meet your needs.
Trish McEvoy Tawny Glaze Eye Shadow Refill
The Trish McEvoy Eye Shadow offers a silky, pigment-rich formula that provides a luminous shimmer finish. You will appreciate how effortlessly it glides on, enhancing your lids with vibrant, stay-true colour that lasts throughout the day. This eye shadow blends and builds easily, allowing you to create any desired look with convenience. Whether you prefer a sheer wash of colour or a more dramatic effect with dimension-enhancing depth, this product adapts to your needs perfectly.
Trish McEvoy Glaze Eye Shadow Refill, Cream
The Trish McEvoy Eye Shadow offers a silky, pigment-rich formula that delivers a beautiful shimmer finish. You will appreciate how easily it glides onto your lids, enhancing your eyes with vibrant and true-to-colour wear. The shadow blends seamlessly, allowing you to build up the intensity for any desired look. Whether you wish for a subtle wash of colour or a more dramatic effect, this product is perfect for highlighting your features, especially in the inner corners and crease of your eyes.
Benecos Natural Cosmetics Vegan Muddy Olive Eyeshadow
The Benecos Muddy Olive Eyeshadow is a highly pigmented eyeshadow that fits perfectly in the IT pieces refill palette. Its soft formulation makes it easy for you to blend, ensuring a seamless finish. Infused with a care complex of organic corn starch, avocado oil, and jojoba oil, this eyeshadow not only enhances your look but also nourishes your skin. Additionally, it is free from talc and is vegan, making it a great choice for those seeking natural beauty products.
Trish McEvoy Fearless Eye Shadow Refill
The Trish McEvoy Eye Shadow offers a silky texture and a luminous shimmer finish, perfect for enhancing your eyelids. It glides on smoothly, providing vibrant, long-lasting colour that stays true throughout the day. You can easily blend and build the colour to create your desired look, whether it's a soft wash or a more dramatic effect. The versatility of this eye shadow allows you to use lighter shades to highlight and darker shades for depth, making it a convenient choice for any eye makeup routine.
Trish McEvoy White Peach Eye Shadow Refill
The Trish McEvoy Eye Shadow offers a silky texture and rich pigmentation, ensuring a luminous shimmer finish that enhances your eyelids beautifully. It glides on smoothly, providing long-lasting colour that stays true throughout the day. You’ll find it easy to blend and build, allowing you to create the perfect look, whether you prefer a subtle wash of colour or a more dramatic effect. This versatile product is ideal for highlighting and adding depth to your eyes, making it a must-have for your makeup collection.
Diego Dalla Palma Matt Eyeshadow - 173 Ever Green
The Diego Dalla Palma Eyeshadow offers a rich, velvety matte texture that enhances your eye makeup effortlessly. With its long-lasting colour formula, you can enjoy vibrant and striking looks throughout the day without the need for constant touch-ups. This product is suitable for all skin types, ensuring that everyone can achieve that perfect matte finish. The matte pressed eyeshadow is designed for easy application, allowing you to create a variety of stunning styles with ease.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How do you revive an eyeshadow palette?
All you have to do is crush up any chunks in your eyeshadow with a toothpick and add a few drops of alcohol. After you've done that, grab a coin or any flat surface and wrap it in a napkin so you can press the powder into place and let it dry!
2. Can you add water to eyeshadow?
"Add water to shadow to make it more intense. Use a small spray bottle to mist your shadow and press the brush into your product. Don't rub or swipe it around because you want to really pack the shadow into the brush. The key is to go easy on the water, adding a little bit at a time.
3. How can I make cheap eyeshadow more pigmented?
First, apply eyelid primer to all of your eye. Then, use a white base to make your eyes pop. Finally, apply a cream eyeshadow and then build layers using powdered eyeshadow. In addition, you can use a little water to make your powdered eyeshadow to make your pigment more bold.
During our refill eyeshadow research, we found 70 refill eyeshadow products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 4,582 customer reviews through our big data system to write the refill eyeshadows list. We found that most customers choose refill eyeshadows with an average price of £13.43.
The refill eyeshadows are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of refill eyeshadows, including MAC, Trish McEvoy, benecos, diego dalla palma. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 96 consumers with an average rating of 4.4.

Charlotte Powell is a dermatologist and a licensed cosmetologist from Westminster, London. However, she was first a cosmetologist from London Beauty Training School. According to Charlotte, she needed better insight into the human skin, hence the dermatology degree. Long before she acquired her degree, she wrote and edited articles, eBooks, and editorials for companies and websites. Charlotte combines her skill and knowledge in providing DIY Beauty tips amongst other fashion related topics.