Best Dermatologist-Tested Eyeliners of 2025

Name: EVAGARDEN Long Lasting Eye Liner
Brand: EVAGARDEN

Charlotte Powell

Last Updated: 29 Jan 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

If you're looking for a reliable and high-quality eyeliner, then you might want to consider trying out some dermatologist-tested options. These eyeliners have been put through rigorous testing to ensure that they are safe and effective for use on the delicate skin around the eyes. With a variety of shades, finishes, and formulas available, you can find an eyeliner that suits your preferences, whether you prefer a bold wing or a subtle line. Plus, with the reassurance of dermatologist testing, you can feel confident that you're making a smart purchase for your beauty routine.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

#TOP 1

EVAGARDEN Long Lasting Eye Liner

9.8

Buy on Amazon Read Review

EVAGARDEN Long Lasting Eye Liner

#TOP1

9.8

Read Review

#TOP 2

L'Oréal Paris Super Liner Perfect Slim Grey Eyeliner

9.7

Buy on Amazon Read Review

L'Oréal Paris Super Liner Perfect Slim Grey Eyeliner

#TOP2

9.7

Read Review

#TOP 3

08 Shimmery Silver Waterline Kohl Eyeliner

9.5

Buy on Amazon Read Review

08 Shimmery Silver Waterline Kohl Eyeliner

#TOP3

9.5

Read Review

Top 8 Dermatologist-Tested Eyeliners

#TOP 1

EVAGARDEN Long Lasting Eye Liner

EVAGARDEN

8023603128010

Black

1.4 g (Pack of 1)

EVAGARDEN Long Lasting Eye Liner - Liquid Formula with Thin Applicator for Precise, Quick Makeup - Emphasize Your Look with Graphics - Set Curves from Light to Dramatic - 01 Black - 0.05 oz

9.8

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

INTENSE, BRILLIANT POP OF COLOR. Dramatic Makeup With No Limits, This Eyeliner Has A Creamy Texture That Is Easy To Blend And Releases Intense Color To The Eyes For A Graphic, Fashion Effect. The Color Remains Uniform And Bright With No Transfer.

CREATES ULTRA-FINE TO BOLD LINES. This Eyeliner Helps To Emphasize Your Eye Look By Drawing Lines From Fine To Bold. Maintain Your Bold And Colorful Appearance All Day Because Of The Solid, Long-Lasting Texture, Which Ensures Excellent Hold.

NO SMUDGE, QUICK DRY APPLICATION. This Eyeliner Helps You Achieve A Clean Eye Makeup Finish Because The Formula Dries Quickly And Does Not Smudge. It Is Simple To Remove Using Makeup Wipes And Will Not Leave A Messy Residue On Your Skin.

MADE IN ITALY. Italian Beauty Brand EVAGARDEN Makes Luxury Cosmetics Using Natural Plant Extracts And Essential Oils. Beyond Just Being Attractive, EVAGARDEN Gives Women The Freedom, Self-Assurance, And Independence They Need To Take On The World.

DERMATOLOGIST TESTED. The Products From EVAGARDEN Have Been Dermatologist-Tested And Are Devoid Of D5, Parabens, And Perfumes. All Skin Types Can Use These Revolutionary, No-Transfer, Waterproof Formulas.

Read more Read less

#TOP 2 Best Grey Eyeliner

L'Oréal Paris Super Liner Perfect Slim Grey Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris

AA212700

Grey

1 count (Pack of 1)

L'Oréal Paris Eyeliner with precise felt tip for the perfect eyeliner and irresistible eye make-up, super liner, perfect slim, no. 02 grey, 1 piece

9.7

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

The L'Oréal Super Liner offers a liquid grey eyeliner with a precise felt tip, ensuring you achieve a perfect eyeliner look every time. Its long-lasting formula provides intense colour, making it perfect for creating classic winged styles, dramatic cat eyes, or alluring smokey eyes. The easy application allows you to glide the eyeliner smoothly along your lash line, while the comfortable wear ensures no smudging throughout the day. With its practical pen shape, handling becomes a breeze, making it a must-have for any makeup enthusiast.

What We Like

Precise application with felt tip

Long-lasting, smudge-proof formula

Intense colour for various looks

Comfortable to wear all day

Easy handling with pen shape

#TOP 3

08 Shimmery Silver Waterline Kohl Eyeliner

Makki

20.23

08 Metallic Silver

1 count (Pack of 1)

08 Shimmery Silver Waterline Kohl Eyeliner - Special Kajal for inner eyelids - vitalizing and Waterproof - sensitive eyes hypoallergenic eye liner

9.5

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

The New 2020 Formula Now Contains Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Seed Oil And Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract Which Have Vitalizing, Relaxing, Regenerating, Moisturizing And Smoothing And Soothing Effects. Your Eyes Will Look Brighter. New Amazing Colours Have Been Added To The Range Already Requested By Many.

MAKKI's Waterline Kohl Eyeliner, A Special Kajal For Inner Eye Lids And For Sensitive Eyes. A New Generation Of Professional Kohl Eyeliner Formulated Specifically For The Delicate Eye Lid Area. Super Soft Glide And Long Stay With Excellent Colour Pay Off On The Waterline.

Ultra Smooth And Super Soft Glide And Super Long Stay: Stays Put For Up To 6 Hours. Intense And Rich Colour. Professional Results. Suitable For All Weather And Climates. Remains Stable And Put In High Temperature And High Humidity Environments. Perfect For Holidays.

Formulated And Manufactured In Accordance With The Strict EU, US And Japanese Regulations

Contains No Mineral Oils And No Preservatives. The Product Is Ophthalmologically And Dermatologically Approved. It Contains No Animal Derived Ingredients And It Is Not Tested On Animals.

Read more Read less

#TOP 4 Best KIKO Milano Eyeliner

KIKO Milano Winged Eyeliner | Long-Lasting And Water-Resistant Eyeliner

KIKO Milano

KM000000225001B

Black

1 count (Pack of 1)

KIKO Milano Winged Eyeliner | Long-Lasting And Water-Resistant Eyeliner

9.3

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

Its Angled Tip Allows For Precise Strokes With An Adjustable Thickness

Long-Lasting And Water-Resistant Eyeliner With An Angled Tip

Ophthalmologically Tested

Its Fluid Texture With An Intense Black Finish Lasts Up To 24 Hours

Ideal For Emphasising Your Eyes With Perfect Flicks And Graphic Lines For A High-Impact Look

Read more Read less

#TOP 5

Eveline Cosmetics Eyeliner Pencil Ultra-Soft Brown Eye Pencil

Eveline Cosmetics

125102

Brown

6.4 g (Pack of 1)

Eveline Cosmetics Eyeliner Pencil Ultra-Soft Brown Eye Pencil with Built-In Sharpener for Precise Application

9.2

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

𝗗𝗲𝘀𝗶𝗴𝗻: Comes With A Built-In Sharpener In The Cap For Precise Tip Maintenance, Allowing For Perfect Line Definition Every Time.

𝗙𝗼𝗿𝗺𝘂𝗹𝗮: Exceptionally Soft Texture That Glides Smoothly On The Eyelids, Ensuring A Gentle And Easy Application.

𝗩𝗲𝗴𝗮𝗻-𝗙𝗿𝗶𝗲𝗻𝗱𝗹𝘆: Made With Vegan Ingredients, Ensuring No Animal-Derived Components In The Product.

𝗙𝗶𝗻𝗶𝘀𝗵: Provides A Natural Brown Shade That Enhances Your Eyes While Maintaining A Subtle And Sophisticated Look.

𝗖𝗼𝗻𝘃𝗲𝗻𝗶𝗲𝗻𝗰𝗲: Ideal For Quick Touch-Ups And On-The-Go Applications, Thanks To Its Compact Design And Integrated Sharpener.

Read more Read less

#TOP 6

Bell HYPOAllergenic Precise Liquid Eyeliner 01, 5 g

Bell HYPOAllergenic

H170

Black

5 g (Pack of 1)

Bell HYPOAllergenic Precise Liquid Eyeliner 01, 5 g

9.1

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

Item_display_weight; 0.013 Kilograms

#TOP 7

Barry M Cosmetics Bold Waterproof Eyeliners Gun Metal

Barry M

BWE6

Gun Metal

1 count (Pack of 1)

Barry M Cosmetics Bold Waterproof Eyeliners Gun Metal

8.9

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

Item Display Weight: 7.0 Grams

#TOP 8

Profusion Cosmetics WING IT Superfine Eye Liner

Profusion Cosmetics

2K432-3

Black

15 g (Pack of 1)

Profusion Cosmetics WING IT Superfine Eye Liner Cover

Profusion Cosmetics WING IT Superfine Eye Liner - Makeup with Long Lasting, Cruelty-free and Wonderful Design Eye Liner

8.8

FTB Score

Buy on Amazon

Find on eBay

Features

WING IT! SUPERFINE BACK EYELINER

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is the healthiest eyeliner pencil?

Overview. Best liquid: NakedPoppy Liquid Eyeliner.Best felt tip: W3LL PEOPLE Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner.Best powder: Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner.Best gel: Burt's Bees Defining Retractable Eyeliner.Best pencil: Kjaer Weis Eye Pencil.Best kohl: Jillian Dempsey Eyeliner.Best pen: Ilia Clean Line Liquid Liner.

Editor's Notes

During our dermatologist-tested eyeliner research, we found 8 dermatologist-tested eyeliner products and shortlisted 8 quality products. We collected and analyzed 34,591 customer reviews through our big data system to write the dermatologist-tested eyeliners list. We found that most customers choose dermatologist-tested eyeliners with an average price of £5.61.

The dermatologist-tested eyeliners are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of dermatologist-tested eyeliners, including EVAGARDEN, L'Oreal Paris, Makki, KIKO Milano, Eveline Cosmetics. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 155 consumers with an average rating of 4.9.

Written by

Charlotte Powell

Charlotte Powell is a dermatologist and a licensed cosmetologist from Westminster, London. However, she was first a cosmetologist from London Beauty Training School. According to Charlotte, she needed better insight into the human skin, hence the dermatology degree. Long before she acquired her degree, she wrote and edited articles, eBooks, and editorials for companies and websites. Charlotte combines her skill and knowledge in providing DIY Beauty tips amongst other fashion related topics.