Best PS4 Mystery Games of 2025

In My Little Pony Mystery, you can dive into an enchanting world where your favourite ponies await. You’ll explore the beautiful kingdom of Zephyr Heights, helping to save the cloud city as you go. The game offers a fun co-op mode, allowing you to team up with a friend or play solo, enhancing your adventure experience. Additionally, you can style your pony friends with delightful custom accessories, making each character unique and more personal to you.

In Rise of the Tomb Raider, players join Lara Croft as she uncovers an ancient mystery while being pursued by the dangerous organisation, Trinity. The new "Blood Ties" single-player story offers a deeper narrative, allowing you to explore Lara's personal journey. With the "Blood Ties" Nightmare mode, you can face chilling challenges that test your skills. Additionally, the 20 Year Celebration content introduces five classic skins and a tribute outfit, giving you more ways to customise your character and enjoy her iconic legacy.

Poirot: The London Case offers a captivating narrative that draws you into the intriguing world of Hercule Poirot. You will explore new environments in a first-person view, allowing for a more immersive experience as you search for vital clues. Engaging with suspicious characters through cinematic conversations enhances the storyline. Additionally, a new minigame feature lets you solve mysteries by matching collected clues, making each investigation feel rewarding and interactive.

Charon's Staircase offers players a captivating first-person interactive fiction experience set in a psychologically thrilling environment. You will uncover a disturbing reality filled with tension and mystery, which keeps you engaged throughout your journey. With the freedom to navigate various levels, you can search for clues and unlock secrets that piece together the intricate story. The beautifully crafted levels enhance the atmospheric experience, immersing you in a world that is both fascinating and overwhelming.

Hercule Poirot: The First Cases invites you to step into the shoes of the legendary detective during his formative years. As you delve into an untold crime story, you will face a complex murder case filled with hidden truths. Engaging with the Van den Bosch family, you must uncover the secrets behind their deceiving appearances. By questioning suspects discreetly, you'll gather crucial information that aids your investigation, enhancing your skills in deduction and critical thinking.

In Destiny PS4, you embark on an epic action adventure to reclaim what was lost during the fall of our Golden Age. You can explore the ancient ruins of our solar system, which allows you to uncover the mysteries that lie within our universe. As a Guardian of the last city on Earth, you will wield incredible power to defeat various enemies threatening the planet. The game also combines cooperative, competitive, and public gameplay, providing you with a vast online world to enjoy with friends and other players.

Hello Neighbor 2 allows you to immerse yourself in the intriguing town of Raven Brooks, where exploration is key. You can traverse various houses and interact with AI-driven characters, adding a rich layer of mystery to your adventure. As an investigative journalist, you will sneak around to uncover your neighbours' hidden secrets. The game challenges you to outsmart intelligent AIs that learn from your actions, making every encounter unique and engaging. It's an exciting opportunity for you to unravel the dark truths that lurk within this captivating community.

Kotodama: Fujisawa Mysteries invites you to explore the hidden truths of Fujisawa Academy through seven intriguing chapters. You will engage in battles using the "Kotodama" technique, where the power of words helps you uncover the reality behind deceitful appearances. The game cleverly plays with anime clichés, ensuring that the storyline offers fresh twists that keep you guessing. Additionally, repeated playthroughs reveal new details, allowing you to unlock the true ending and a complete gallery of artworks, enhancing your overall gaming experience.

Syberia 3 invites you to immerse yourself in a captivating world crafted by Benoit Sokal. You will discover an enchanting, fully explorable 3D environment brimming with mystery and life. As you unravel the deep and rich story, innovative new puzzles and riddles will challenge your problem-solving skills, combining various elements in intriguing ways. Meeting a host of intriguing characters will provide you with vital clues, allowing you to make choices that influence your journey through the game.

Control Ultimate Edition offers an immersive experience where you can uncover the bureau's dark secrets while searching for your missing brother. You'll have the power to transform your weapons and utilise telekinetic abilities, turning your surroundings into lethal tools for combat. As you delve into the hidden world of a secretive government agency, you'll find that the bureau's shifting environments hide more than you think. Engage in thrilling battles against relentless enemies, completing exciting missions that allow you to earn powerful upgrades and customise your weaponry to enhance your gameplay.