Best PS5 Mystery Games of 2026

Hercule Poirot: The London Case offers players a captivating narrative that immerses you in the intriguing world of the famous detective. You'll explore various environments in a first-person view, searching for clues while engaging with new and suspicious characters in a cinematic manner. The game introduces a unique minigame feature that allows you to solve mysteries by matching collected clues and contradicting characters' alibis. Additionally, the optimised engine enhances 3D isometric renders, bringing more depth and life to each scene, making your investigative experience even more enjoyable.

Alan Wake 2 offers an engaging psychological horror experience, where you can solve a deadly mystery that unfolds with unexpected twists. As you play, you'll switch between two intriguing characters, Alan Wake and Saga Anderson, seeing the story from various perspectives. You’ll explore two beautifully crafted yet terrifying worlds, enhancing your journey with rich narratives. Additionally, you'll learn to survive against powerful supernatural foes, using light as your ultimate weapon, which adds a unique strategy to your gameplay.

In the My Little Pony Game, you can play with your favourite ponies and dive into the enchanting world of Zephyr Heights. You get to explore the stunning cloud city while helping to save it, providing an exciting adventure for you. Enjoy the thrill of co-op gameplay, allowing you to team up with one or two players for even more fun. Additionally, you can personalise your pony friends with custom accessories, making each character truly unique and stylish.

Life is Strange: True Colors invites you to step into the shoes of Alex Chen, who possesses a unique ability to sense and manipulate others' emotions. This power is essential as you uncover the truth behind your brother's mysterious death, ensuring an emotional journey that keeps you engaged. You will forge deep relationships with townsfolk, allowing you to build trust and explore friendships or romance. The game offers a truly personal experience, enabling you to make impactful choices that shape Alex's future and style.

In Gotham Knights for PS5, you step into a world where Batman has fallen, leaving the Batman Family to defend Gotham City. You will engage in thrilling battles against notorious villains while unraveling the city’s darkest mysteries. The game allows you to explore an expansive, dynamic open world either solo or with a friend, patrolling five distinct boroughs. Each encounter brings the opportunity to bring hope to citizens and instil fear in criminals, ensuring that you evolve into the new Dark Knight.