Best Carbon Steel Pie Pans of 2025

Mohammed Clark Avatar
Mohammed Clark
Last Updated: 9 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Carbon steel pie pans are a popular choice for baking enthusiasts who want to achieve a perfectly crispy crust. These pans are made from durable and long-lasting carbon steel, which is known for its excellent heat retention and distribution properties. The non-stick surface ensures easy release of the pie, while the sturdy construction makes it suitable for use in high-temperature ovens. Whether you're a professional baker or a home cook, carbon steel pie pans are a must-have in your kitchen for creating delicious and evenly cooked pies.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

RHBLME 20 Pack Mini Pie Pans Cover #TOP 1
RHBLME 20 Pack Mini Pie Pans
ftb score rating icon 9.9
MasterClass 23 cm Deep Non-Stick Pie Dish Cover #TOP 2
MasterClass 23 cm Deep Non-Stick Pie Dish
ftb score rating icon 9.8
MasterClass Crusty Bake 23 cm Pie Dish Cover #TOP 3
MasterClass Crusty Bake 23 cm Pie Dish
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Carbon Steel Pie Pans

#TOP 1

RHBLME 20 Pack Mini Pie Pans

RHBLME
Mini Pie Tins
Black
5 inches
RHBLME 20 Pack Mini Pie Pans Cover
RHBLME 20 PACK Mini Pie Pans, 5 Inch Reusable Small Pie Pans Nonstick Small Pie Tins, Carbon Steel Pie Pans for Baking, Round Bread and Meat Pie Tins for Cake Bread Meat Dessert

The RHBLME Mini Pie Pans are crafted from high-quality carbon steel, ensuring durability and resistance to scratching. With their oven and dishwasher safety, you can easily bake and clean up without hassle. The non-stick coating makes it a breeze to remove your baked goods, helping you maintain their perfect shape. Additionally, the rolled edge design offers comfortable handling, making your baking experience even more enjoyable.

What We Like
Durable carbon steel material
Oven and dishwasher safe
Non-stick for easy release
Comfortable rolled edge design
#TOP 2

MasterClass 23 cm Deep Non-Stick Pie Dish

KCMCHB15
Black
23cm
MasterClass 23 cm Deep Non-Stick Pie Dish Cover
MasterClass 23 cm Deep Pie Dish with PFOA Non Stick, Robust 1 mm Carbon Steel, 9 Inch Round Pan

The MasterClass Pie Dish is an excellent choice for baking enthusiasts. Its 1 mm-thick carbon steel construction ensures supreme strength, preventing any rusting or warping during use. The electroplated finish adds to its durability, making it a long-lasting kitchen companion. With a depth of 5 cm (2 inches), this pie dish provides ample space for a variety of fillings, from rich meat and vegetable mixes to sweet and tangy apple pies. You will appreciate the non-stick feature, which allows for easy release of your baked goods, simplifying the cleanup process.

What We Like
Durable carbon steel construction
Deep design for ample filling
Non-stick for easy release
Electroplated finish prevents rust
#TOP 3

MasterClass Crusty Bake 23 cm Pie Dish

KCMCCB15
Grey
23cm
MasterClass Crusty Bake 23 cm Pie Dish Cover
MasterClass KCMCCB15 Crusty Bake 23 cm Deep Perforated Pie Dish with PFOA Non Stick, Robust 1 mm Carbon Steel, 9 Inch Round Tin, Grey

The MasterClass Pie Dish is designed to help you achieve perfect pies every time. Its award-winning perforated design allows moisture to escape, ensuring you no longer have to deal with soggy bottoms. The deep 23 cm size is perfect for sharing medium-sized sweet and savoury pies, and with a depth of 5 cm, your creations will have plenty of room to rise. Made from robust 1 mm carbon steel, this pie dish provides durability and even heat distribution, giving you crispier results that enhance your baking experience.

What We Like
Prevents soggy bottoms
Deep design for sharing
Durable carbon steel material
Crispier baking results
#TOP 4

Stellar SB61 24cm Non-Stick Deep Pie Tin

SB61
Black
24cm x 24cm x 3cm
Stellar SB61 24cm Non-Stick Deep Pie Tin Cover
Stellar SB61 Deep Pie Tin, Carbon Steel, Dishwasher Safe 24cm x 24cm x 3cm - 5 Year Non-Stick Warranty

The Stellar SB61 Pie Tin is designed for baking delicious deep fill pies, featuring sloping sides and a small lip that make crust pinching easy. Constructed from high-grade 1mm carbon steel, it ensures even cooking for professional results, so your pies will come out perfectly every time. The rolled edges add strength and safety, eliminating sharp edges and preventing warping. With a long-lasting double layer non-stick coating, your pies will lift out cleanly, making clean-up a breeze, whether you wash by hand or pop it in the dishwasher.

What We Like
Durable carbon steel construction
Easy to clean non-stick surface
Safe, rolled edges
Ideal for deep fill pies
#TOP 5

RHBLME Mini Pie Pans Set of 10

RHBLME
Mini Pie Tins
Black
5 inches
RHBLME Mini Pie Pans Set of 10 Cover
RHBLME 10 PACK Mini Pie Pans, 5 Inch Reusable Small Pie Pans Nonstick Small Pie Tins, Carbon Steel Pie Pans for Baking, Round Bread and Meat Pie Tins for Cake Bread Meat Dessert

The RHBLME Mini Pie Pans are crafted from high-quality carbon steel, ensuring durability and resistance to scratches. Their oven and dishwasher compatibility brings convenience, allowing you to bake and clean with ease. With a non-stick coating, you can effortlessly remove your baked goods without any mess, preserving their perfect shape. The rolled edge design ensures comfort when handling, making your baking experience enjoyable and hassle-free.

What We Like
Durable carbon steel material
Oven and dishwasher safe
Non-stick for easy removal
Comfortable rolled edge design
Great for various occasions
#TOP 6

HLODEFFO 12 Pack Nonstick Mini Pie Pans

HLODEFFO
Mini Pie TIns
Black
HLODEFFO 12 Pack Nonstick Mini Pie Pans Cover
HLODEFFO 12 Pack Nonstick Mini Pie Tins, 5 Inch Reusable Small Pie Pans Carbon Steel Pie Pans for Baking Pies Cakes Tarts Desserts

The HLODEFFO Mini Pie Pans are crafted from premium carbon steel, ensuring long-lasting durability and excellent performance in your kitchen. The nonstick coating allows you to effortlessly remove your baked goods without any mess, keeping them in perfect shape. Cleaning up is a breeze as these pans are dishwasher safe, saving you valuable time after cooking. The roll-up edge design enhances comfort during use, making it easier for you to hold and manoeuvre the pans while baking your favourite treats.

What We Like
Durable carbon steel material
Nonstick for easy release
Dishwasher safe for convenience
Comfortable roll-up edge design
Value pack of 12 pans
#TOP 7

Quyimy 8 Pack Mini Pie Pans with Brush

Quyimy
Pie Pans
Gold
5 Inch
Quyimy 8 Pack Mini Pie Pans with Brush Cover
Quyimy 8 Pack Mini Pie Pans, 5 Inch Mini Pie Tins Gold Reusable Round Small Pie Pans, Carbon Steel Mini Tart Pan Nonstick Round Small Pie Tins for Baking Dessert, Fruit Pie and Meat Pie

The Quyimy Mini Pie Pans are expertly designed for effortless baking. Their elegant edge design ensures comfortable handling while promoting even heat distribution, resulting in perfectly baked pies. Made from premium carbon steel, these pans are durable and safe for food preparation, making them a reliable choice for various baking tasks. Additionally, each set comes with a silicone brush to help you oil the pans easily before use, enhancing your baking experience. Ideal for both everyday treats and special occasions, these pans make baking enjoyable.

What We Like
Elegant edge design
Durable carbon steel material
Includes silicone oil brush
Nonstick for easy release
Dishwasher safe for convenience
#TOP 8

Chicago Metallic Split Decision Pie Pan

CMET26719
Metallic
24 cm
Chicago Metallic Split Decision Pie Pan Cover
Chicago Metallic CMET26719 Professional 'Split Decision' Non Stick Split Pie Pan / Tart Tin with Divider and Loose Bottom, In Gift Box, Carbon Steel, 24 cm

The Chicago Metallic Pie Pan is perfect for those who can't decide on a single flavour. With its unique divided design, you can bake two different pie halves simultaneously, allowing you to enjoy both apple and blackberry or cherry and almond pies at the same time. If you need a traditional tart, simply switch to the flat base for a classic tart tin. The easy-release non-stick feature ensures your pies come out smoothly, making clean-up a breeze, whether washed by hand or in the dishwasher.

What We Like
Two flavours in one pan
Easy to clean
Non-stick for quick release
Versatile for tarts and pies
#TOP 9

BLMHTWO 5 Inch Nonstick Mini Pie Tins

DY328-CFX-1
Black
BLMHTWO 5 Inch Nonstick Mini Pie Tins Cover
BLMHTWO 2 Pieces Individual Pie Tins, 5 Inch Mini Pie Pans Pie Dish for Baking Carbon Steel Black Round Nonstick Mini Pie Tins for Baking Bread Cake Tart Desserts Meat

The BLMHTWO Mini Pie Tins are crafted from high-quality carbon steel, ensuring excellent thermal conductivity for even baking. With a size of approximately 5 inches, they are perfect for creating individual treats for everyone. The non-stick coating allows your baked goods to release effortlessly, making clean-up a breeze. These versatile tins are suitable for a wide range of recipes, from cakes to mini quiches, making them a fantastic addition to your kitchen essentials.

What We Like
High-quality carbon steel
Non-stick for easy release
Versatile for various recipes
Easy to clean
Perfect for individual servings
#TOP 10

Quyimy Mini Pie Pans 4 Pack

Quyimy
Pie Pans
Gold
5 Inch
Quyimy Mini Pie Pans 4 Pack Cover
Quyimy 5 Inch Mini Pie Pans 4 Pack Pie Tins Gold, Carbon Steel Mini Tart Pan Nonstick Round Small Pie Tins for Baking Pot Pies Cakes Pizza Bread Dessert, Fruit Pie and Meat Pie

The Quyimy Mini Pie Pans are crafted from premium carbon steel, ensuring durability and safety for all your baking needs. Their nonstick coating allows cakes and pies to slide out effortlessly, making your baking experience enjoyable. The included red silicone brush helps you oil the pans with ease, while the silicone scrubber simplifies the cleaning process. With elegant edges designed for comfort and even heat distribution, these mini pie pans are perfect for creating delightful desserts for any occasion.

What We Like
Durable carbon steel construction
Nonstick for easy release
Includes silicone brush and scrubber
Elegant design for stylish baking
Versatile for various occasions
Buying Guide Image
Editor's Notes

During our carbon steel pie pans research, we found 55 carbon steel pie pans products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 14,190 customer reviews through our big data system to write the carbon steel pie pans list. We found that most customers choose carbon steel pie pans with an average price of £20.61.

The carbon steel pie pans are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of carbon steel pie pans, including RHBLME, MasterClass, Stellar, HLODEFFO, Quyimy.

Written by
Mohammed Clark Avatar

Mohammed Clark is an architect and a contractor. His architectural skills are not limited to designing the plan for structures alone, but it extends to aesthetics and home décor. Before establishing his firm, he worked under a construction firm for eight years. Mohammed has gathered enough experience from his time practicing as a professional architect and now has vast knowledge in home designs and aesthetics.