Best Pirates Cake Toppers of 2025

Kiera Browne Avatar
Kiera Browne
Last Updated: 9 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Pirates Cake Toppers are a great way to add a touch of adventure to any cake. These toppers feature classic pirate imagery such as skulls and crossbones, treasure chests, and pirate ships. They are made from high-quality materials and are easy to place on top of cakes or cupcakes. These toppers are perfect for pirate-themed parties or for adding a fun twist to any celebration. With their attention to detail and durable construction, Pirates Cake Toppers are sure to be a hit with both children and adults.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Handmade Edible Pirate Cake Toppers Set Cover #TOP 1
Handmade Edible Pirate Cake Toppers Set
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Edible Pirate Cake Topper for Kids Cover #TOP 2
Edible Pirate Cake Topper for Kids
ftb score rating icon 9.7
Culpitt Pirate Ship Cake Topper Decoration Cover #TOP 3
Culpitt Pirate Ship Cake Topper Decoration
ftb score rating icon 9.5

Top 10 Pirates Cake Toppers

#TOP 1

Handmade Edible Pirate Cake Toppers Set

SugArt
ectsetan
Pirate
Handmade Edible Pirate Cake Toppers Set Cover
4x Edible Pirate Cake Toppers Set - Handmade Icing Fondant Pirate Ship Bag Map Birthday Baby Showers Cupcake Decor Supplies Comes with an Edible Glue

The SugArt Pirate Cake Toppers are crafted from high-quality sugar paste, making them completely edible and safe for all your sweet treats. These vibrant toppers instantly transform your child's birthday cake into a lively pirate adventure. They are versatile decorations suitable for any age, perfect for birthdays, baby showers, or pirate-themed parties. With included designs of a pirate boy, ship, bag, and map, you can easily create a stunning cake that dazzles guests and enhances your celebration.

What We Like
Edible and safe for consumption
Bright and colourful designs
Suitable for various occasions
Easy to use and insert
#TOP 2

Edible Pirate Cake Topper for Kids

SugArt
Multicolour
Edible Pirate Cake Topper for Kids Cover
jncakes Cake Topper Pirate Party Decoration Fondant Fabulous Edible Icing Great for Kids Boy Girl 10 Year Old Easy To Use Icing Professional

The SugArt Pirate Topper is a delightful addition to any cake or cupcake, made from edible sugar paste for a safe and tasty decoration. Its glossy surface and clear texture printing will make your cake look vibrant, adding a magical touch to your birthday celebrations. This versatile topper is perfect for various occasions, whether it's a special birthday party or a school event. Each handmade topper is eye-catching, ensuring your cake stands out and brings joy to your guests.

What We Like
Edible and safe material
Vibrant, glossy design
Multipurpose for various events
Handmade for unique appeal
#TOP 3

Culpitt Pirate Ship Cake Topper Decoration

20125
Multicolour
Culpitt Pirate Ship Cake Topper Decoration Cover
Culpitt Pirate Ship Pic Cake Topper, 1 Pc, Gum Paste Cake Decorations For a Fun Birthday Cake, Colourful Time-Saving Topper, Multicolour, 20125

The Culpitt Pirate Ship Topper is an excellent choice for adding a splash of colour and fun to any birthday cake. Its bright and adventurous design instantly enhances the cake's appeal. Unlike traditional toppers, this one is straightforward to use; simply insert it into the cake, saving you time and effort. Made from durable gum paste, it holds securely in place, ensuring your decoration stays intact throughout the celebration. Plus, it employs safe food colourings, making it a worry-free option for your party.

What We Like
Bright and colourful design
Easy to use and insert
Durable and secure placement
Safe food colourings used
#TOP 4

AK Giftshop Pirate Party Cup Cake Toppers

Multi
AK Giftshop Pirate Party Cup Cake Toppers Cover
AK Giftshop Pirate Party Pack, 36 Cup Cake Toppers - Edible Stand Up Decorations

The AK Giftshop Cake Toppers are a fantastic addition to your baking for any pirate-themed celebration. These toppers come pre-cut, so you won’t need to worry about any additional preparation; simply apply them directly to your cakes. Made from fully edible, premium quality wafer card, they ensure that your treats not only look good but are also safe to eat. Each topper is approximately 5cm in size, making them ideal for cupcakes, fairy cakes, muffins, buns, and cookies. They are suitable for vegetarians and vegans, as well as being gluten and nut-free, catering to a wide range of dietary needs.

What We Like
Pre-cut for easy application
Fully edible and safe
Perfect size for various treats
Vegetarian, vegan, and allergy-friendly
#TOP 5

Personalised Pirate Ship Birthday Cake Topper

Personalised Pirate Ship Birthday Cake Topper Cover
Pirate Ship Happy Birthday Personalised 7.5 INCH Edible Icing Cake Topper Decoration B094

The Pirate Ship Cake Topper is a delightful addition to any birthday celebration. At 7.5 inches, this precut topper is easy to place on your cake, making decorating a breeze. Made from 100% edible materials, you can enhance your cake's appearance without compromising on safety. The vibrant image is printed on premium icing sheets, ensuring a clear and sharp design that will impress your guests. Each topper features a decorative border, adding an extra touch of elegance to your cake.

What We Like
Easy to use
Safe and edible
Vibrant, sharp image
Unique design with border
#TOP 6

PartyDeco Pirate Cake Topper Set

KPT41
Schwarz
PartyDeco Pirate Cake Topper Set Cover
Pirate Cake Topper, Pirate Ship cake Topper

The Pirate Cake Topper from PartyDeco is a delightful addition to any pirate-themed celebration. With a mix of designs and colours, these toppers stand approximately 13.5 cm to 21 cm tall, making them eye-catching decorations for your cake. Each pack contains five pieces, providing ample options to enhance your party décor. The beautiful design is sure to impress your guests and will bring joy to your child as they see their cake adorned with these fantastic decorations.

What We Like
Vibrant designs and colours
Height range for visibility
Five pieces per pack
Perfect for pirate-themed parties
Enhances cake decoration
#TOP 7

Orange Trading Pirate Treasure Map Cake Topper

Orange Trading Pirate Treasure Map Cake Topper Cover
Orange Trading Dartmouth LTD A4 Treasure Map Pirate Wallpaper Edible Cake Topper Decoration - Great for larger cakes

The Orange Trading Cake Topper is a delightful A4 edible decoration featuring a pirate treasure map design. This topper is printed on a high-quality icing sheet using edible inks, making it easy for you to enhance your cake's appearance. Simply peel off the plastic backing and place it on your iced cake for an instant transformation. With a shelf life of at least 12 months, you can conveniently keep it on hand for future celebrations. Enjoy the creativity it brings to your baking!

What We Like
Easy to apply
Long shelf life
Fully edible
Attractive design
#TOP 8

24 Precut Pirate Cake Toppers by Top That

Multicolored
24 Precut Pirate Cake Toppers by Top That Cover
24 PRE Cut Pirate Themed Edible Wafer Paper Round Cake Toppers Decorations

The Top That Pirate Toppers are a delightful addition to any children's party. With 24 precut edible wafer paper cake toppers, you can easily decorate your cakes with charming pirate-themed images. These toppers come in convenient 40mm circles, allowing you to place them directly on your cakes without any hassle. Crafted with edible inks, they are fully edible and safe for everyone to enjoy. This means you can add a fun and festive touch to your celebrations while ensuring that your guests can indulge in every bite.

What We Like
Easy to use
Fun pirate designs
Fully edible
Perfect for children's parties
Precut for convenience
#TOP 9

Personalised Edible Pirate Cake Topper

AMZ20103
White
Edible Icing
Personalised Edible Pirate Cake Topper Cover
Personalised Pirate Cake Topper - Edible Pirate Cake Decoration - 7.5" Round (Edible Icing)

Enhance your cake with the Debs Kitchen Cakes Topper, a personalised cake decoration that adds a unique touch to any celebration. You can easily customise your cake topper by providing names or messages through the 'Customize Now' button. The round topper measures 7.5" and is available in both edible icing and wafer options. Plus, it is gluten-free and suitable for vegetarians and vegans, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice of the cake adorned with this delightful decoration.

What We Like
Customisable for personal touch
Two edible material options
Gluten-free and vegan-friendly
Professionally made and safe
#TOP 10

Personalised Pirate Cake Toppers by Debs Kitchen Cakes

AMZ20100
Multicoloured
Personalised Pirate Cake Toppers by Debs Kitchen Cakes Cover
Personalised Pirate Cake Toppers - Treasure Island Cake Decorations - PRE-CUT - Edible Wafer - 4cm x 24

Make your celebrations even more special with Debs Kitchen Cakes Toppers. These personalised cake toppers allow you to easily add names or messages to your cakes; simply click the 'Customize Now' button to get started. Each set includes 24 pre-cut edible wafer toppers, measuring 4cm, so there’s no need for cutting. They are also gluten-free and suitable for vegetarians and vegans, ensuring everyone can enjoy them. With these toppers, you can create a memorable cake that looks professional and tastes great.

What We Like
Personalised messages for cakes
Pre-cut for easy application
Gluten-free and vegan-friendly
24 toppers per set
Professional quality from Debs Kitchen
Buying Guide Image
Editor's Notes

During our pirates cake topper research, we found 52 pirates cake topper products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 3,819 customer reviews through our big data system to write the pirates cake toppers list. We found that most customers choose pirates cake toppers with an average price of £5.05.

The pirates cake toppers are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of pirates cake toppers, including SugArt, Culpitt, AK Giftshop, Cannellio Cakes, PartyDeco. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 114 consumers with an average rating of 4.7.

Written by
Kiera Browne Avatar

Kiera Browne served as chef and caterer in Purslane Restaurant for three years before establishing her restaurant. Kiera now owns two restaurants and a culinary school all over the United Kingdom. Kiera has featured in magazines and editorials, providing recipes for various dishes. Using her skills and knowledge in the culinary field, Kiera has published few pamphlets on preparing various cuisines.