Best Aftershave Balms for Oily Skin of 2025

Phoebe Cooper Avatar
Phoebe Cooper
Last Updated: 2 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Aftershave balms for oily skin are a must-have for any man who struggles with excess oil after shaving. These balms are specially formulated to soothe and hydrate the skin while also helping to control oil production. They are typically lightweight and non-greasy, so they won't leave your skin feeling heavy or clogged. Whether you have sensitive skin or just want to keep your complexion looking its best, these aftershave balms are a great choice.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

NIVEA MEN Sensitive Pro Ultra Calming Balm Cover #TOP 1
NIVEA MEN Sensitive Pro Ultra Calming Balm
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Proraso Refreshing Aftershave Balm with Eucalyptus Oil Cover #TOP 2
Proraso Refreshing Aftershave Balm with Eucalyptus Oil
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Bart's Balm Aftershave Balm for Sensitive Skin Cover #TOP 3
Bart's Balm Aftershave Balm for Sensitive Skin
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Aftershave Balms for Oily Skin

NIVEA MEN Sensitive Pro Ultra Calming Balm

White
150 ml (Pack of 1)
NIVEA MEN Sensitive Pro Ultra Calming Balm Cover
NIVEA MEN Sensitive Pro Ultra Calming Facial Balm (150 ml), Aftershave Balm Enriched With Hemp Seed Oil And Vitamin E For Stress-Minimising Face Care

The NIVEA MEN Ultra Calming Balm is designed specifically to soothe and relieve the signs of skin stress, such as dryness and irritation after shaving. Enriched with 100 percent organic hemp seed oil and vitamin E, this balm is both vegan and microplastic-free, making it kind to your skin and the environment. Its non-greasy formula absorbs quickly, ensuring you won’t feel sticky or oily, even if you have facial hair. Dermatologically approved for sensitive skin, it helps you maintain visibly healthy skin throughout the day.

What We Like
Soothes shaving irritation
Vegan and eco-friendly formula
Fast absorbing, non-greasy texture
Suitable for sensitive skin

Proraso Refreshing Aftershave Balm with Eucalyptus Oil

8004395001101
600 ml (Pack of 1)
Proraso Refreshing Aftershave Balm with Eucalyptus Oil Cover
Proraso Aftershave Balm, 100ml, Refreshing Alcohol-Free Post Shave Balm with Eucalyptus Oil and Menthol Invigorates Skin, Made in Italy, Green

The Proraso Aftershave Balm is designed to provide immediate relief after shaving. It is alcohol-free and enriched with Eucalyptus Oil and Menthol, which helps to moisturise and restore your skin's balance. This balm offers a revitalising effect that combats post-shave irritation while hydrating your skin. Its fast-absorbing, non-greasy formula combines the benefits of a balm and a cream, ensuring you receive soothing comfort right after your shave.

What We Like
Alcohol-free formula
Fast-absorbing and non-greasy
Hydrates and refreshes skin
Reduces post-shave irritation
Made in Italy

Bart's Balm Aftershave Balm for Sensitive Skin

Bart's Balm
Nevis100
100 ml
Bart's Balm Aftershave Balm for Sensitive Skin Cover
BART'S BALM Aftershave Balm For Men 100ml Handmade- Argan Oil - Amber and Moroccan Jasmine - Sensitive After Shaving Skin Care

Bart's Balm Aftershave is a handmade solution for men who experience irritation after shaving. It is designed to soothe razor burn and reduce redness, making it ideal for sensitive skin. The balm is enriched with natural ingredients like Argan Oil, Vitamin E, and Grapeseed Oil, which work to repair and nourish your skin. This lightweight, non-greasy formula also provides intense hydration, helping to restore moisture lost during shaving, ensuring you look and feel your best.

What We Like
Soothes razor burns effectively
Contains natural, nourishing ingredients
Lightweight and non-greasy
Handmade in the UK
Intensely hydrates skin
#TOP 4

RECIPE FOR MEN After Shave Balm with Matte Finish

100 ml (Pack of 1)
RECIPE FOR MEN After Shave Balm with Matte Finish Cover
RECIPE FOR MEN After Shave Balm, Non-Oily Formula, Fights Redness & Irritation, Light Moisturizer, Instant Matte Finish, 100 ml

The RECIPE FOR MEN After Shave Balm is designed to soothe your skin after shaving. Its non-oily formula effectively fights redness and irritation, ensuring you feel comfortable and refreshed. This light moisturiser helps your skin recover from dryness, leaving it feeling soft and hydrated. Additionally, the balm features Abyssine protection, which calms and shields your skin with a unique protective molecule. You will also appreciate how it eases discomfort from razor burn, thanks to the inclusion of allantoin. Enjoy a smoother, more comfortable shaving experience.

What We Like
Fights redness and irritation
Lightweight moisturiser
Soothes razor burn
Instant matte finish
#TOP 5

Percy Nobleman Recovery Balm for Men

66468
Black
100 ml (Pack of 1)
Percy Nobleman Recovery Balm for Men Cover
Recovery Balm by Percy Nobleman. Aftershave Balm. Post Shave. Oil Control Moisturiser for Men 100ml, black

The Percy Nobleman Recovery Balm is an excellent aftershave product designed with an age-defence formula. It helps relieve itchiness, making your shaving experience much more comfortable. With soothing anti-inflammatory natural ingredients, it works to regenerate damaged skin barriers after shaving. Additionally, it heals, protects, and moisturises your skin, while also controlling excess oil. This means you can enjoy a fresh and revitalised complexion without the worry of shine. Perfect for men seeking an effective post-shave solution.

What We Like
Soothes post-shave irritation
Regenerates skin barriers
Controls excess oil
Natural ingredients
SLS free

Helan M Oud Gentle Aftershave Balm

150BMOU
75 ml (Pack of 1)
Helan M Oud Gentle Aftershave Balm Cover
Helan M Oud - Mens Aftershave Balm Gentle & Moisturising, Calming Action against Irritation - Soothing Aftershave Men with Vitamin E, Linseed & Macadamia Oils, Gifts for Him - Made in Italy, 75 ml

Helan M Oud Balm is an ideal choice for those with sensitive skin. Its soothing properties help alleviate razor irritation, making your shaving experience more comfortable. Formulated with natural ingredients like Linseed and Macadamia Nut oils, it nourishes the skin while Vitamin E combats free radicals, helping to keep your skin feeling soft and youthful. This non-alcoholic balm absorbs quickly, providing instant relief from burning sensations and dryness after shaving.

What We Like
Soothes razor irritation
Nourishes with natural oils
Quick absorption
Non-alcoholic formula
Ideal for sensitive skin

L'OCCITANE Homme Cap Cedrat After Shave Balm

20AR075HC20
Cap Cedrat
75 ml (Pack of 1)
L'OCCITANE Homme Cap Cedrat After Shave Balm Cover
L'OCCITANE Homme Cap Cedrat After Shave Balm 75ml | Fresh & Invigorating Scent | Vegan & 97% Readily Biodegradable | Luxury & Clean Men's Beauty Grooming for All Skin Type

The L'OCCITANE After Shave Balm is a refreshing solution for your post-shave routine. It is designed to be applied over the face and neck, particularly soothing any areas of irritation you may have. This balm not only moisturises your skin but also helps prevent feelings of tautness, ensuring comfort after shaving. Its rapid absorption leaves no oily residue, making it ideal for daily use. Experience a luxurious and clean grooming product suitable for all skin types.

What We Like
Fresh and invigorating scent
Vegan and biodegradable
Moisturises and soothes skin
Absorbs quickly, non-oily
Suitable for all skin types

Alphy & Becs Sandalwood Aftershave Balm

AFTERSHAVE_SANDALWOOD
100 ml (Pack of 1)
Alphy & Becs Sandalwood Aftershave Balm Cover
Aftershave Balm - Sandalwood, Bergamot and Patchouli.

The Alphy & Becs Aftershave Balm is a fantastic choice for those seeking a natural grooming product. It is free from SLS, parabens, and petroleum, ensuring a gentle application on your skin. Enriched with St. John's Wort oil and Macadamia oil, it nourishes and hydrates, helping to soothe any irritation after shaving. The inclusion of pure essential oils provides a delightful fragrance, enhancing your post-shave routine. Plus, being vegan-friendly, this balm allows you to care for your skin with a clear conscience.

What We Like
Natural ingredients
Soothes skin irritation
Delightful fragrance
Vegan friendly
#TOP 9

TrueFitt & Hill Trafalgar Aftershave Balm 100ml

100 ml (Pack of 1)
TrueFitt & Hill Trafalgar Aftershave Balm 100ml Cover
TrueFitt & Hill 100ml Trafalgar Aftershave Balm

The Trafalgar Aftershave Balm by TrueFitt & Hill is a luxuriously rich and soothing moisturiser designed for your post-shave routine. Its lightly fragranced, non-oily formula provides instant comfort, helping to relieve any irritation you may experience after shaving. You will appreciate how quickly it absorbs, leaving your skin looking shine-free and feeling refreshed. This balm ensures a smooth finish, making your shaving experience not only more pleasant but also enhancing your overall grooming routine.

What We Like
Luxurious moisturiser
Soothes shaving irritation
Non-oily formula
Absorbs quickly
#TOP 10

Haryali London Alum Block Astringent Shaving Accessory

1 count (Pack of 1)
Haryali London Alum Block Astringent Shaving Accessory Cover
Haryali London Alum Block - Astringent Alum Block Shaving Accessory - Antiseptic Alum Block Stone Shaving Block - Soothing After Shave Balm Men and Women - Clear Plastic Case - for All Skin Types

The Haryali London Alum Block is an exceptional aftershave solution that offers a variety of benefits for your skin. This highly antiseptic and astringent block effectively helps to stop bleeding and soothes your skin after shaving, making it ideal for anyone prone to irritation. It dries abrasions and reduces blemishes, ensuring you feel fresh and confident throughout the day. Additionally, this natural deodorant provides long-lasting protection against body odour, keeping you odour-free for longer.

What We Like
Highly antiseptic and soothing
Reduces blemishes effectively
Long-lasting body odour protection
Suitable for all skin types
Economical and value for money
Buying Guide Image
Editor's Notes

During our aftershave balm for oily skin research, we found 29 aftershave balm for oily skin products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 33,919 customer reviews through our big data system to write the aftershave balms for oily skin list. We found that most customers choose aftershave balms for oily skin with an average price of £15.54.

The aftershave balms for oily skin are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of aftershave balms for oily skin, including Nivea Men, Proraso, Bart's Balm, Recipe for Men, Percy Nobleman.

Written by
Phoebe Cooper Avatar

In 2000, Phoebe Cooper graduated from the University of London as a Pharmacist. She practiced as a Pharmacist for the better part of 2 decades. Phoebe says she has worked in the majority of health sectors and has sufficient accumulated knowledge and experience. In her practice, Phoebe published a series of eBooks, one of which is titled "Good Health Good Living."