Best Commander Collectible Card Games of 2025

Edward West Avatar
Edward West
Last Updated: 8 Feb 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Commander Collectible Card Games are a popular type of trading card game that involves players building decks of cards representing magical spells, creatures, and artifacts. The goal of the game is to reduce the opponent's life total to zero while strategizing against their own opponents. With a wide range of characters, creatures, and spells to choose from, players can customize their decks to suit their playstyle and preferences. These games are enjoyed by players of all ages and skill levels, offering a fun and engaging way to spend time with friends and family.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Science! Cover #TOP 1
Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Science!
ftb score rating icon 9.9
Magic The Gathering Commander Karlov Mansion Deck Cover #TOP 2
Magic The Gathering Commander Karlov Mansion Deck
ftb score rating icon 9.8
Vault X Exo-Tec Modular Deck Box for TCG Cards Cover #TOP 3
Vault X Exo-Tec Modular Deck Box for TCG Cards
ftb score rating icon 9.6

Top 10 Commander Collectible Card Games

#TOP 1

Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Science!

D26100000
Multicolor
Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Science! Cover
Magic: The Gathering Fallout Commander Deck - Science! (100-Card Deck, 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack + Accessories)

The Fallout Commander Deck offers an exciting 100-card experience with 38 new Magic cards. You can dive right into thrilling 3–5 player battles, enjoying strategic gameplay with friends. By choosing the Science! deck, you ally with Dr. Madison Li, gaining the advantage of technology in your quest. Additionally, you'll receive a Collector Booster Sample pack, featuring two special cards, including a Rare or Mythic Rare card, enhancing your collection significantly.

What We Like
New and unique cards
Ready-to-play right out of the box
Includes a Collector Booster pack
Engaging for multiple players
Strategic gameplay with thematic elements
#TOP 2

Magic The Gathering Commander Karlov Mansion Deck

D30430000
Multicolored
Magic The Gathering Commander Karlov Mansion Deck Cover
Magic The Gathering Commander Karlov Mansion Murders Deck - Clues Fishing (100 Card Deck, 2 Sample Booster + Accessories) (English Version)

The Karlov Mansion Commander Deck invites you to immerse yourself in a thrilling investigation. With a ready-to-play green-white-blue deck, you can generate Clue Tokens and draw your own conclusions right from the box. Enjoy epic multiplayer battles, where strategy and conspiracy reign supreme. This deck features 12 unique Commander cards that have never been seen before, including two Premium Legendary Creature cards, enhancing your gameplay experience significantly.

What We Like
Ready-to-play out of the box
Unique Commander cards included
Encourages strategic multiplayer gameplay
Includes special collector booster
#TOP 3

Vault X Exo-Tec Modular Deck Box for TCG Cards

VX-EX02-02MGN
Green
Sideloading
Vault X Exo-Tec Modular Deck Box for TCG Cards Cover
Vault X Exo-Tec Modular Sideloading Deck Box Module for 100+ TCG Cards. Detachable Magnetic Lid. Fits Commander & Standard Trading Cards(Green)

The Vault X Deck Box is a robust solution for storing your trading cards. Its premium build features a water-resistant exterior and a soft microfiber lining, ensuring your cards are well protected. The detachable magnetic lid allows you to keep your playing area tidy by securing the lid to the bottom of the box. With eight strong magnets, you can rest assured that your cards won't spill. Additionally, its modular design means it works seamlessly with Vault X's other deck boxes, making organisation a breeze.

What We Like
Durable, water-resistant exterior
Detachable magnetic lid
Compatible with other Vault X boxes
Soft microfiber lining
#TOP 4

TiMOVO MTG Commander Deck Box with Display

P840156959285
Black/Blue
TiMOVO MTG Commander Deck Box with Display Cover
TiMOVO MTG Commander Deck Box, Magnetic Leather Card Deck Case Fits 200+ Double-Sleeved Cards, Card Box with 2 Commander Display & 4 Dividers & Dice Tray Fit YuGiOh TCG CCG Magic Cards, Black & Blue

The TiMOVO Deck Box is perfect for EDH Commander players, offering a stylish display window for your Commander cards. With the capacity to hold over 200 double-sleeved cards, you can easily access your deck during play thanks to its unique U-shaped opening. It also includes a dice tray, keeping all your gaming essentials organised and within reach. Crafted from premium PU leather, this deck box provides robust protection against shocks and dust, ensuring your cards stay safe and scratch-free.

What We Like
Ample storage for cards
Stylish display for Commander cards
Robust protection from damage
Easy access during gameplay
Includes dice tray for convenience
#TOP 5

Magic The Gathering Wonder Commander Card

CMA44
Blue
Magic The Gathering Wonder Commander Card Cover
Magic The Gathering - Wonder - Commander Card - 1 Piece

The Magic The Gathering Wonder Card is an individual card from the popular trading card game. With its Uncommon rarity, it adds a unique touch to your collection. Being part of the Commander set, it is perfect for players who enjoy building customised decks. This card allows you to enhance your gameplay experience, offering new strategies and possibilities. Whether you are a seasoned player or just starting, this card can provide valuable options for your tactics.

What We Like
Uncommon rarity adds uniqueness
Part of popular Commander set
Enhances gameplay strategies
Individual card for collectors
#TOP 6

Magic The Gathering Commander Legends Game Box

localization_B08NYZRR94
Magic The Gathering Commander Legends Game Box Cover
Magic The Gathering Commander Legends 1 Game Box, French - At Random, Commander Deck, Cardstock, Portable, Classic Style, Unisex

The Commander Legends Game Box from Magic The Gathering offers a unique way to enjoy the classic tabletop card game. With cards presented in French, it adds an exciting twist to your gaming experience. The portable design allows you to take your game anywhere, whether for casual play or serious competitions. The cardstock quality ensures durability, meaning your cards will withstand frequent use while maintaining their appearance. This unisex product is perfect for players of all ages, making it an excellent addition to any collector's deck.

What We Like
Portable design for easy transport
Durable cardstock for longevity
Unique French cards for variety
Suitable for all ages
#TOP 7

Magic The Gathering Sword of Vengeance Card

Magic The Gathering Sword of Vengeance Card Cover
Magic The Gathering - Sword of Vengeance - Commander (2014 Edition) - 1 Card

The Magic The Gathering Card is a standout collectible from the Commander (2014 Edition) series. As an individual card, it provides players with unique strategies and gameplay opportunities, enhancing your deck's versatility. Being part of the collectible card game category, it allows you to expand your collection and engage with fellow enthusiasts. This card is specifically designed for Commander format, offering a tailored experience that can elevate your gaming sessions with friends.

What We Like
Unique gameplay strategies
Enhances your card collection
Designed for Commander format
Engages with fellow enthusiasts
#TOP 8

Magic: The Gathering Planeswalker Party Deck

D2606000
Multicolor
Magic: The Gathering Planeswalker Party Deck Cover
Magic: The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck - Planeswalker Party (100-Card Deck, 2-Card Collector Booster Sample Pack & Accessories)

The Planeswalker Party Deck is an excellent choice for those looking to elevate their Commander experience. It offers a powerful, ready-to-play deck that is perfect for jumping straight into the action. You will enjoy playing with Commander’s greatest hits, featuring reprints of iconic cards that are sure to impress your friends. Additionally, this deck introduces 10 never-before-seen cards, providing fresh strategies and surprises for your games. With its Blue-Red-White colour scheme, this deck allows for dynamic gameplay in thrilling multiplayer battles.

What We Like
Ready-to-play out of the box
Features iconic reprinted cards
Includes exclusive new cards
Supports exciting multiplayer gameplay

Magic The Gathering Doctor Who Commander Deck

D23671000
Multicoloured
Magic The Gathering Doctor Who Commander Deck Cover
Magic The Gathering Doctor Who Commander Deck - Time Has A Knick (Deck of 100 Cards, Collector's Booster Trial Pack with 2 Cards + Accessories) (German Version)

The Doctor Who MTG Deck brings the beloved characters and stories from the iconic BBC series to life in a stunning 100-card collection. You will enjoy exploring new strategies with 50 unprecedented cards, enhancing your gameplay experience. The ready-to-play design allows you to dive straight into Commander format, making multiplayer battles exciting and engaging. Plus, with 10 Planechase cards, you can travel through the Doctor Who universe, introducing unique mechanics and effects into your games.

What We Like
Unique Doctor Who-themed cards
Ready-to-play deck included
Multiplayer Commander experience
Planechase cards for added fun
Collector's booster sample pack
#TOP 10

IVODEELA Magnetic Card Deck Box for MTG

UK-T318 BB
Black Blue
IVODEELA Magnetic Card Deck Box for MTG Cover
IVODEELA Card Deck Box for MTG Commander,Magnetic Card Display Case with Two Dividers,TCG Card Storage Box,PU Leather Trading Card Storage Box Holds 100 Double-Sleeved Cards,Black Blue

The IVODEELA Card Deck Box is specially designed for Magic The Gathering enthusiasts, offering exceptional protection and organisation for your cards. With a large capacity, it comfortably holds up to 100 double-sleeved cards, ensuring you have ample space for your deck. The U-shaped wide mouth opening and flip-cover design allow for easy access to your cards, making gameplay smooth and hassle-free. Constructed from durable PU leather and featuring strong magnets, this box provides full protection for your valuable cards, making it a reliable companion for any card game lover.

What We Like
Large capacity for multiple cards
Easy access during gameplay
Durable PU leather construction
Secure magnetic closure
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How much are Commander decks worth?

There aren't any big-ticket cards that you can resell to make your money back, but the deck's value sits around the $60 mark, which is 50% more than MSRP.

2. Are the Commander decks worth buying?

These cards generally take two to three years to really get going, but they can end up being worth $20+ if you're patient. Overall, however, you should feel safe buying Commander 2021 cards, either as complete decks or as singles. These cards rarely end up being complete busts, and can often be incredibly lucrative.

3. Can Commander cards be used in modern?

These cards are legal for play in the Commander, Vintage, and Legacy formats. They aren't legal for play in the Standard, Pioneer, or Modern formats.

4. Is Commander exactly 100 cards?

903.5a Each deck must contain exactly 100 cards, including its commander. In other words, the minimum deck size and the maximum deck size are both 100. 903.5b Other than basic lands, each card in a Commander deck must have a different English name.

Editor's Notes

During our commander collectible card game research, we found 109 commander collectible card game products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 28,990 customer reviews through our big data system to write the commander collectible card games list. We found that most customers choose commander collectible card games with an average price of £25.13.

The commander collectible card games are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of commander collectible card games, including Magic The Gathering, Vault X, TiMOVO, IVODEELA.

Written by
Edward West Avatar

Edward's family owns a retail store in Edinburgh for toys and games. He grew up taking a very active part in the family's business. Edward earned his first income from writing web content on a toy related gig for an online company. When he was 18, he took over from his father, and since then, he has been in charge and management of the store and several others around England.